15
« on: 28 Mar 2013, 14:49 »
I’m not sure it’s fair to characterise it as a reaction to Resonance winning lots of awards. I’m sure everyone here would agree it thoroughly deserved them and it is right that commercial games like that (Gemini Rue, Cat Lady, Journey Down etc.) are showcased and recognised by the community also.
I also don’t think it’s right to judge freeware and commercial games on the same turf. If we did so then, with respect to all concerned, there would not be many freeware games here that anyone got that excited about. For instance, I happily consider many freeware games made here as excellent, and a lot more as very good, but if I’d had to pay money for them I would likely view them differently. Only my own perspective obviously.
Furthermore, I feel that it should be the case that a commercial game is better than a freeware game, otherwise why is the creator charging/not charging for it?
Personally I would like to see the honours shared and both types of game rewarded in separate categories of some kind. I'm not saying that Blackwell Epiphany or Resonance 2 etc. wouldn't deserve to clean up at a future award ceremony, but it would be nice to see non commercial games recognised alongside them in one or more specific category.