I never said that Noa's voice was *bad* nor did I say that she shouldnt be in the band.
All I said was that the songs chosen don't use her voice type particularly effectively.
You wouldn't get Pavarotti to sing a grindcore track... although that might actually be awesome.
Calin, I think you may have misunderstood Dan. Unless I missed it while going back through the posts, nobody has accused you of saying her voice was bad or she shouldn't be in the band... as far as I can tell, you didn't
... so I don't understand why you would say that.
I understood Dan's reply to your comment as only defending his opinion of her voice with the songs we chose. He thinks they were perfectly fine for her voice and you think they don't work well for her type of voice. I found nothing wrong with your opinion. Nobody was upset with you. Hopefully Dan can back me up on this.
I'm sorry for being long winded, Calin (as I always am), but I just took your post as being offended by something that I didn't see happen. If I am misinterpreting the entire thing, please tell me
Hell, I'm still awaiting someone to tell me if my solo (first solo in Comfortably Numb) was up to par or if it could have been done differently/better. I can take it, I'm a big boy
Everybody is entitled to write what they think of the music... unless they're a little arrogant cunt who writes, "YOU GUYZ SUCKZ0RZ!!1!!"
/cue the Babar