Adventure Game Studio

Creative Production => Competitions & Activities => Topic started by: Stupot on Fri 01/11/2024 01:51:57

Poll
Question: What is your favourite game of MAGS November?
Option 1: Gill Bus Party (by jwalt) votes: 3
Option 2: Bad to the Coral (by Rootbound) votes: 3
Option 3: Botos do Diabo (by Babar and jfrisby) votes: 4
Title: MAGS November “Body of Water” (RESULT)
Post by: Stupot on Fri 01/11/2024 01:51:57
The winner of MAGS November was Botos do Diabo (by Babar and jfrisby)

Theme: Body of Water
Set by: Babar and jfrisby
Deadline: November 30th





(https://i.imgur.com/b0ZzIt6.png)GillPartyBus (https://www.mediafire.com/file/v29hekj8q9e642p/GillPartyBus.zip/file)
by jwalt
(https://www.adventuregamestudio.co.uk/images/games/2803_1_thumb_200.png)Bad to the Coral (https://www.adventuregamestudio.co.uk/site/games/game/2803-bad-to-the-coral/)
by Rootbound
(https://img.itch.zone/aW1hZ2UvMzE0NjY1OS8xODgwMzQ5My5wbmc=/original/yoAp9k.png)Botos do Diabo (https://www.adventuregamestudio.co.uk/site/games/game/2808-botos-do-diabo/)
by Babar and jfrisby

The majority of your game must take place in/on/around a large body of water, something bigger than a pool.

(https://currentaffairs.adda247.com/wp-content/uploads/multisite/sites/5/2022/04/08125021/Lakes.png)





What is MAGS?
Started in 2001, MAGS is a competition for amateur adventure game makers. The idea is to create a game in under a month, following the guidelines set by the previous winner. It aims to help you work to a deadline, improve your skills, and provide a kick-start into making adventure games. Regardless of skill, MAGS is for everyone. Voting is based on "favourite" games, and not the most artistic, or the best coded. If you have bad art skills, use it as a chance to do some graphic work. If you're sub-standard at coding, use it as a chance to give scripting a go. Ultimately, people will vote for the most enjoyable entry.

Rules
Entering MAGS is simple. First, conceptualize your game following the month's criteria (see above). Second, create your game fuelled only by coffee. Finally, post your game in this thread, including:

* A working download link
* The title of your game
* A suitable in-game screenshot

At the end of the month, voting will begin, usually lasting for fourteen days, and the winner chooses the next month's theme.

Remember that this is a challenge to see what you can do in a month, so any tinkering you do after that, including fixing minor glitches, is against the spirit of the competition. The exception to this is that you may go in and fix major, game-breaking bugs only during voting. We want you to have a game that voters can actually play and that runs on their machines.

So to reiterate, during the voting period fixing major, game-breaking bugs is okay, fixing minor glitches or making cosmetic changes is cheating.

Tips
Here are some ways to make sure you have a game to submit at the end of the month:
* Make a tiny game. Plan small, then cut it in half. Find shortcuts (e.g. if making walkcycles is time-consuming, make the characters static or have it in the first person).
* Plan to have your game playable and submittable with a week to spare. This way you have a week to fix bugs, add some flourishes and maybe even get someone to test it.
* Plan to submit it a day or so early. This way, if there are any technical issues with uploading, they can be sorted out in time.


++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Need a little help with graphics? Perhaps The AGS Trove (https://www.adventuregamestudio.co.uk/forums/index.php?topic=55998.0) has something you can use.
Don't want to go it alone? Try the Recruitment board (https://www.adventuregamestudio.co.uk/forums/index.php?board=20.0).
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++


Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: jwalt on Sat 02/11/2024 13:02:51
So, how about under a large body of water. Started toying around with this:

(https://i.imgur.com/qGOeKgs.png)

Not rigged, and not anatomically accurate.

They can have hitchhikers on their backs, including the fornicating limpet (Crepidula fornicata). Seems to offer some clever dialogue between the horseshoe crab and its riders: "what's going on back there, don't make me come back there, are we there yet"... Lots of possibilities. Fornicata, who can resist that? Now, to come up with something to challenge our hero, and a background in which the yet unknown tale can be told. I might be in on this one. Depends on what storyline I can come up with and whether I can rig my model.
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: jwalt on Sun 03/11/2024 12:57:05
Quick question... Since I'm setting my thing up as taking place under water, any opinions about using a GUI overlay to fake it? Is it even necessary? So far, with the overlay color I'm using, it just makes everything look foggy.

I've made quite a bit of progress, so far. Probably going to just be a single room, outside the intro and credits. I think I've made a decent walk cycle for my hero, and there will be fornicating limpets in my game. Hopefully Stupot will not have to X-rate my game.

Edit: I've made some unbelievable progress and, along with some good fortune, I'm able to play through the game I envisioned. I've more to do, for sure, but by tidying up a few things, it might stand as an entry, as is. It's almost entirely a video, but if anyone wants to see my WIP, here's the MediaFire link:

Spoiler
https://www.mediafire.com/file/cpkgim0xgjj739m/PartyBus.zip/file
[close]

I haven't option-offed the dialogues, and I've put Roger to use in a couple of places. He'll be invisible in a completed game. Also, not sure that I've tested all the possible things that happen if you start backtracking through the areas. Still working on it, and still have most of the month remaining. Plenty of time for me to totally mess it all up.

Edit: Information about the link is no longer accurate. I messed up uploading the actual game, then found out I'd left off the intro room. I had to upload it, again, with the final version. You probably will be wasting your time on the link above, if it even works after I messed it up.
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: VampireWombat on Mon 04/11/2024 11:51:56
I wasn't sure if I was going to do more than just offer to help someone make a game, but I guess I will be trying to make a Monkey Island type game. I was trying to get back to sleep and the video I chose to do so sparked enough an idea to lead to decent fleshing out of ideas already.

If anyone is familiar with The Longest Johns, a couple of their songs are inspiration to some degree. Whether or not there will actually be some kind of water based cryptid/monstrous waterfowl is still to be determined.
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: pell on Mon 04/11/2024 16:34:32
I'm trying to think of something while my game dev hat is still on.

Does anyone have a premise or idea you're not using that you'd like to see made into a MAGS game this month? I'd like to have something nailed down very early so the rest of the month can be spent implementing the game.
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: VampireWombat on Mon 04/11/2024 17:14:18
Quote from: pell on Mon 04/11/2024 16:34:32I'm trying to think of something while my game dev hat is still on.

Does anyone have a premise or idea you're not using that you'd like to see made into a MAGS game this month? I'd like to have something nailed down very early so the rest of the month can be spent implementing the game.
I don't have any specific suggestions, but you could always look into public domain sources for ideas. You could look into mythology. Perhaps something involving selkies or a kelpie. Or you could get inspiration from The Odyssey. Perhaps a public domain book like Robinson Crusoe or Treasure Island.
Or you could randomly choose a location with a large enough body of water and look into legends from that area. There are so many possibilities. The main thing I'd ask is what kind of game do you want to make? DO you want something mystery related? You could do a murder mystery on an tiny island. You could do something like what if some Agatha Christy story happened on that island and adjust things accordingly.
If you want more ideas or want to bounce ideas back and forth, feel free to ask.
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: pell on Mon 04/11/2024 18:31:04
Quote from: VampireWombat on Mon 04/11/2024 17:14:18
Quote from: pell on Mon 04/11/2024 16:34:32I'm trying to think of something while my game dev hat is still on.

Does anyone have a premise or idea you're not using that you'd like to see made into a MAGS game this month? I'd like to have something nailed down very early so the rest of the month can be spent implementing the game.
I don't have any specific suggestions, but you could always look into public domain sources for ideas. You could look into mythology. Perhaps something involving selkies or a kelpie. Or you could get inspiration from The Odyssey. Perhaps a public domain book like Robinson Crusoe or Treasure Island.
Or you could randomly choose a location with a large enough body of water and look into legends from that area. There are so many possibilities. The main thing I'd ask is what kind of game do you want to make? DO you want something mystery related? You could do a murder mystery on an tiny island. You could do something like what if some Agatha Christy story happened on that island and adjust things accordingly.
If you want more ideas or want to bounce ideas back and forth, feel free to ask.

Thank you. I think I'm going with the mystery/quest approach. I already have a story idea based on a premise heltenjon sent me. It looks like I'm in for this month if nothing unexpected comes up (like a soon-to-be hurricane that's supposedly aiming right for us).
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: RootBound on Tue 05/11/2024 19:16:40
I may attempt a one-room-one-week entry. Fingers crossed that I'll have the time and energy.
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: cat on Tue 05/11/2024 20:50:42
According to Wikipedia, the human body consists of 70% water. Does this qualify as "Body of Water"?
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: Ponch on Tue 05/11/2024 22:55:49
Quote from: Stupot on Fri 01/11/2024 01:51:57The majority of your game must take place in/on/around a large body of water, something bigger than a pool.
What about a very large swimming pool? Or an incredibly long slip-n-slide?  :=
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: RootBound on Tue 05/11/2024 23:32:32
Quote from: Ponch on Tue 05/11/2024 22:55:49What about a very large swimming pool? Or an incredibly long slip-n-slide?  :=
Sounds like a water park would do it.
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: tbook on Fri 08/11/2024 09:07:36
I have the story  :=
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: jwalt on Sat 09/11/2024 17:57:40
I'm going to call this done, since I'm not at all sure of what may happen after a doctor's appointment on Monday. I may not be able to do anything more with it, depending on what the doctor finds out. 

Here's the link:

https://www.mediafire.com/file/v29hekj8q9e642p/GillPartyBus.zip/file

It should now be the complete game, or as complete as it may ever be.

Here's the screen capture:

(https://i.imgur.com/b0ZzIt6.png)

Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: Tabata on Sat 09/11/2024 19:12:16
@jwalt
(https://i.imgur.com/lq7Y0Px.gif)  I somehow found myself!?
What an impressive work on animating eyebrows!    (https://i.imgur.com/hii5ht3.gif)


Also best of luck for your appointment on monday!
                           (https://i.imgur.com/v0IyWsJ.gif)
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: RootBound on Mon 11/11/2024 18:01:02
7 days down and my one-room-one-week game is playable!!  ;-D It's a bit rough and has features missing, but I will definitely have something to submit.  :)
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: VampireWombat on Tue 12/11/2024 13:41:07
Since Adventure X has a gamejam starting this weekend, that's going to end up being higher priority. I'm not going to abandon this game, but it'll be shorter than I had originally planned and will be using low res graphics.
And while writing this, I came up with a new idea which will extend the game without need of more than a couple of extra assets.
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: RootBound on Fri 15/11/2024 15:35:31
My entry is complete! If anyone wants to test it before I link to it here, just let me know. It's a one-room arcade game, "completable" in a couple minutes or less. Longer if you keep trying to beat your high score (which is the whole point).
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: heltenjon on Sun 17/11/2024 02:14:46
Quote from: jwalt on Sat 09/11/2024 17:57:40It should now be the complete game, or as complete as it may ever be.
Hey, this was really funny! Still mostly a cartoon, but entertaining? Absolutely!
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: VampireWombat on Wed 20/11/2024 13:39:49
I got recruited to work on a game for a voice actor's Adventure X game. So, I don't know if I'll be able to finish a game for MAGs or not. Definitely won't be able to do any of the ideas I had. I'll see if I can figure out something, though.
Good luck to those working on games.
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: RootBound on Thu 21/11/2024 12:55:30

BAD TO THE CORAL: The most relaxed you'll ever be while frantically trying to stop environmental destruction.


A classic fast-paced arcade-style game with calming sound effects.

Protect a delicate coral reef from an endless cascade of garbage. Gain reef health by letting red algae accumulate and by stemming the flow of trash for extended periods. Get extra points with combos. How long can you keep the reef alive?

AGS DATABASE LINK:
https://www.adventuregamestudio.co.uk/site/games/game/2803-bad-to-the-coral/

OFFICIAL PAGE: https://rootbound.itch.io/bad-to-the-coral
(https://www.adventuregamestudio.co.uk/images/games/2803_1_thumb_200.png)
(https://img.itch.zone/aW1hZ2UvMzEyMDAwNS8xODY3MDYyNi5wbmc=/794x1000/bi8p%2F6.png)
(https://img.itch.zone/aW1hZ2UvMzEyMDAwNS8xODY3MDYyNS5wbmc=/794x1000/f62sES.png)

Uses the Tween module by @edmundito
Huge thanks to @Nahuel for testing.
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: RootBound on Fri 22/11/2024 01:22:21
As I wrote in the completed games thread, it seems I uploaded an older build of the game by accident. If you downloaded it (it seems not many people did yet), please replace it with the new version. Same download link. I feel very silly. (wrong)
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: RootBound on Sun 24/11/2024 21:30:17
@jwalt, I just played your entry. It was fun, and I really like the animation! Would love to see more in this vein with the pre-rendered assets.
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: RootBound on Tue 26/11/2024 12:52:20
For those who may not have time to play very much, here's a full playthrough with me adding a new score to my high score list at the end.


Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: pell on Fri 29/11/2024 20:17:39
I'm bowing out. I was very excited about the script I came up with, but the puzzles were kind of meh, so I got distracted with other things.
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: RootBound on Sat 30/11/2024 14:22:48
So there's a new version of my entry uploaded because I found a bug that freezes the game instead of displaying the high score list. It's fixed now. You'll need to complete a playthrough before the update will go into your save games, though. Or you can delete your saves (which will clear the high score list). Everything else is the same, no changes to gameplay or anything else.
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: Kara Jo Kalinowski on Sat 30/11/2024 17:06:40
These are 2 very different games, will be interesting to see how the vote goes.
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: jfrisby on Sun 01/12/2024 05:04:08

Babar & I present...
BOTOS DO DIABO
A fever dream horror somewhere in the Amazon...

(https://img.itch.zone/aW1hZ2UvMzE0NjY1OS8xODgwMzQ5My5wbmc=/original/yoAp9k.png) (https://img.itch.zone/aW1hZ2UvMzE0NjY1OS8xODgwMzQ3Mi5wbmc=/original/QHPT2p.png) (https://img.itch.zone/aW1hZ2UvMzE0NjY1OS8xODgwMzQ5NC5wbmc=/original/UflIeF.png)

Download: https://jfrisby.itch.io/botos-do-diabo (https://jfrisby.itch.io/botos-do-diabo)

This one has some violence, blood, *scares, etc.. if you're sensitive to that (*AGS level jumpscares). It got pretty experimental and weird this month. :p
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: TheFrighter on Sun 01/12/2024 10:25:03

Cool!  8-)

Just a minor nuisance: you didn't indicate the OS!

_
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: jfrisby on Sun 01/12/2024 13:25:56
Quote from: TheFrighter on Sun 01/12/2024 10:25:03Just a minor nuisance: you didn't indicate the OS! _

Thanks for catching this, I was pretty tired when I uploaded it.. We'll have a linux build up soon too!
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: Babar on Sun 01/12/2024 16:28:45
Quote from: jfrisby on Sun 01/12/2024 05:04:08Babar & I present...
BOTOS DO DIABO
A fever dream horror somewhere in the Amazon...

(https://img.itch.zone/aW1hZ2UvMzE0NjY1OS8xODgwMzQ5My5wbmc=/original/yoAp9k.png) (https://img.itch.zone/aW1hZ2UvMzE0NjY1OS8xODgwMzQ3Mi5wbmc=/original/QHPT2p.png) (https://img.itch.zone/aW1hZ2UvMzE0NjY1OS8xODgwMzQ5NC5wbmc=/original/UflIeF.png)

Download: https://jfrisby.itch.io/botos-do-diabo (https://jfrisby.itch.io/botos-do-diabo)

This one has some violence, blood, *scares, etc.. if you're sensitive to that (*AGS level jumpscares). It got pretty experimental and weird this month. :p
Since we got no "STOP NOW CRIMINAL SCUM!" from Stupot yet, I've uploaded some final tweaks, and added a linux build as well. Same link as before. Enjoy, everyone (including me, who will now relax with the other entries).
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: RootBound on Tue 03/12/2024 11:56:43
Quote from: jfrisby on Sun 01/12/2024 05:04:08Babar & I present...
BOTOS DO DIABO
A fever dream horror somewhere in the Amazon...

Spoiler
well the leg scene was genuinely horrifying. Good job making the game playable and intuitive throughout the strangeness.

Spoiler
I have a bit of a science-fiction brain, so I have a hypothesis that maybe explains all of this (in a forced and totally unnecessary way. The game works better as a fever dream without explanation).
Spoiler
The character is "unstuck in time" in the vein of Slaughterhouse-five. Once he gets to the end of his life, he starts traveling through time backwards. He wrote the note warning himself to watch his legs, and he wrote the note from his lover because he knew he would never die before ever reaching home, and wanted to release himself from longing for her, despite the pain it would cause. He took the baby from the raft because he knew that traveling forward in time would not save the baby either, so he carries the baby with him now, traveling further into the past, and when he gets far enough in time before the flood that the baby will have a chance to grow up, he will release it back into the regular time stream. The baby then grows up and becomes him.

...As I said, the game is better without anything like this.  (laugh)
[close]
[close]
[close]
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: lapsking on Tue 03/12/2024 13:34:09
Botos Do Diabo
Spoiler
A good short game. Limited pallet works well and having few colors helps with creating the ambience without becoming boring, since it's a short game. The interface is easy and puzzles are straight forward. Using some inventory items on some objects are left without any explanation or reaction from the character. For me, having a story (even though fever dream) was a bonus. It successfully creates an eerie atmosphere.
[close]

Bad to the Coral
Spoiler
A very polished game. Creative idea, conscious topic and nice graphics. I enjoyed the different gameplay.
[close]

Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: jfrisby on Tue 03/12/2024 18:01:30
Quote from: RootBound on Tue 03/12/2024 11:56:43
Spoiler
well the leg scene was genuinely horrifying. Good job making the game playable and intuitive throughout the strangeness.

Spoiler
I have a bit of a science-fiction brain, so I have a hypothesis that maybe explains all of this (in a forced and totally unnecessary way. The game works better as a fever dream without explanation).
Spoiler
The character is "unstuck in time" in the vein of Slaughterhouse-five. Once he gets to the end of his life, he starts traveling through time backwards. He wrote the note warning himself to watch his legs, and he wrote the note from his lover because he knew he would never die before ever reaching home, and wanted to release himself from longing for her, despite the pain it would cause. He took the baby from the raft because he knew that traveling forward in time would not save the baby either, so he carries the baby with him now, traveling further into the past, and when he gets far enough in time before the flood that the baby will have a chance to grow up, he will release it back into the regular time stream. The baby then grows up and becomes him.

...As I said, the game is better without anything like this.  (laugh)
[close]
[close]
[close]
I love all this so much! :D

Spoiler
.. and its probably super generous to the reality of the plot in this :D  (Poor Jackson, and whatever he is raking in?!)
That makes the bottle make sense a lot more, ..and the baby stuff!
I'd drawn a bunch of closeup's that seemed fun, and we tried our best to cobbled them together..  it seems like a lot of horror kind of feels like that though?  Just a series of very emotionally manipulative scenes :D  Thanks for the kind words!
[close]

Spoiler
I enjoyed Bad to the Coral too, drawing a bunch of trash looked fun!  I really wanted to assign nets to hotkeys for net-size (1-3?) but that might make it too intense :D
[close]
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: Kara Jo Kalinowski on Tue 03/12/2024 21:04:41
Quote from: jfrisby on Tue 03/12/2024 18:01:30
Quote from: RootBound on Tue 03/12/2024 11:56:43
Spoiler
I enjoyed Bad to the Coral too, drawing a bunch of trash looked fun!  I really wanted to assign nets to hotkeys for net-size (1-3?) but that might make it too intense :D
[close]

I agree with this 100%, if there was a version 1.01 or something that's definitely something that should be added
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (OPEN)
Post by: Stupot on Fri 06/12/2024 03:24:34
Sorry for the delay, everyone.
Time to vote.

(https://i.imgur.com/b0ZzIt6.png)GillPartyBus (https://www.mediafire.com/file/v29hekj8q9e642p/GillPartyBus.zip/file)
by jwalt
(https://www.adventuregamestudio.co.uk/images/games/2803_1_thumb_200.png)Bad to the Coral (https://www.adventuregamestudio.co.uk/site/games/game/2803-bad-to-the-coral/)
by Rootbound
(https://img.itch.zone/aW1hZ2UvMzE0NjY1OS8xODgwMzQ5My5wbmc=/original/yoAp9k.png)Botos do Diabo (https://www.adventuregamestudio.co.uk/site/games/game/2808-botos-do-diabo/)
by Babar and jfrisby

As always, let me know if I've missed anything in my haste.
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (VOTING)
Post by: lapsking on Sun 08/12/2024 11:15:05
I missed playing GillPartyBus. Just saw it yesterday.

Spoiler
It was more of a humorous short animation rather than a game. It didn't have puzzles and interaction and look at buttons mainly did the same thing. Nevertheless, it was a fun experience.
[close]

Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (VOTING)
Post by: cat on Sun 08/12/2024 21:13:05
GillPartyBus
Spoiler
Fun setting, great dialog writing but like in the previous game, there nothing to do. It's not a game but a short film.
That Tabata eyebrow inside joke made me really laugh out loud and I was glad to see the crab in its new home in the end.
[close]

Bad to the Coral
Spoiler
Interesting concept. I liked the sprites of the falling objects a lot. I played it for a while in slow mode until it became boring, then in fast mode until I died (which didn't take a long time). Maybe I'll try that again another day but I stopped now because my hand started to hurt.
A keyboard short cut for choosing the net would have been a nice UI feature.
[close]

Botos Do Diabo
Spoiler
So, this is quite difficult to review for me. The graphics are wonderful, again a great color scheme and lots of detailed drawings and animations (was the baby based on a photo of your baby?).
The story was flowing like the river, but gameplay felt like just clicking to trigger the next chapter. Which from a philosophical point of view fits the theme, but wasn't that much fun to play.
The atmosphere was amazing, with a great build-up of tension. However, as a climax, there was the scene with the leg. I didn't manage to solve the only real puzzle of the game in time and died. I didn't have a save file, so I had to play again from the beginning. This means that I tried to get by as fast as possible and the complete atmosphere was ruined for me and not restored for the rest of the game. Having an autosave right at the beginning of the scene might have prevented this. But the way I experienced the game, I was left with an indifferent feeling (which might be a good thing after all, since I actually don't like horror).
[close]

My vote
Spoiler
Ok, this is a difficult one. From the production value, Botos Do Diabo is a clear winner, with Bad to the Coral a close second. But especially for MAGS, I like to judge games by the way I feel after completing them. After playing Bad to the Coral, my wrist hurt. After playing Botos Do Diabo, I was somewhat disappointed because of the ruined atmosphere. So, in the end, I voted for GillPartyBus, because it made me laugh.
[close]
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (VOTING)
Post by: Babar on Mon 09/12/2024 03:05:22
Quote from: cat on Sun 08/12/2024 21:13:05Botos Do Diabo
Spoiler
So, this is quite difficult to review for me. The graphics are wonderful, again a great color scheme and lots of detailed drawings and animations (was the baby based on a photo of your baby?).
The story was flowing like the river, but gameplay felt like just clicking to trigger the next chapter. Which from a philosophical point of view fits the theme, but wasn't that much fun to play.
The atmosphere was amazing, with a great build-up of tension. However, as a climax, there was the scene with the leg. I didn't manage to solve the only real puzzle of the game in time and died. I didn't have a save file, so I had to play again from the beginning. This means that I tried to get by as fast as possible and the complete atmosphere was ruined for me and not restored for the rest of the game. Having an autosave right at the beginning of the scene might have prevented this. But the way I experienced the game, I was left with an indifferent feeling (which might be a good thing after all, since I actually don't like horror).
[close]
Thanks for the very honest feedback!
Spoiler
We went back and forth on whether the game should feature death on that scene (and the sinking and the tourniquet) several times, and only finally plugged in the death hours before the deadline. We had assumed that 50 seconds would be more than enough time to solve the puzzle, but I think your idea of an autosave is good, and something we can implement, post-MAGS).
[close]
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (VOTING)
Post by: cat on Mon 09/12/2024 07:49:17
Quote from: Babar on Mon 09/12/2024 03:05:22
Spoiler
We had assumed that 50 seconds would be more than enough time to solve the puzzle
[close]

Spoiler
I know, quite embarrassing that I didn't solve it. But I was really feeling the pressure and stress. I focused on the leg and tried all inventory items again and again and just didn't look somewhere else. The game really got me until this point.
[close]
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (VOTING)
Post by: heltenjon on Tue 10/12/2024 01:59:02
Here are my thoughts this month.

GillPartyBus by jwalt:
Spoiler
Funny, and also nice use of the rendered graphics. There's not much interaction, though I liked what there was. (But I miss Josh and Davy!)
[close]

Bad to the Coral by Rootbound:
Spoiler
I think this is a great non-adventure game with very good replayability on hard mode. Slow mode is too easy. Of course, it's a limited game genre, but I was impressed by how good it delivers. Possibly a contender against CaptainD for the non-adventure AGS award this year?
[close]

Botos do Diabo by Babar and jfrisby:
Spoiler
Very atmospheric and plenty of WTF moments. I liked this one a lot, being a horror fan and all. However, the game is on tracks with little branching. In a sense, this one and GillPartyBus are similar in that regard. Both games involve going forward and dealing with what appears on the player's way.
[close]

My vote:
Spoiler
Rootbound. This was a very hard decision. I think I've voted for Babar and jfrisby every time so far in MAGS, and voting for something other than an adventure is not something I would normally do. But I admire Rootbound's little action game, as it proves the versatility of AGS.
[close]
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (VOTING)
Post by: Babar on Tue 10/12/2024 15:20:52
Was hard to choose between the two other entries.
Spoiler
In the end, I just went with Gill's Party Bus, for mostly the same reasons as last month. Silly humour, and cute art and animations (and fittingly silly music this time too, although I understand it wasn't made for the game specifically).
Bad to the Coral was technically pretty cool, but I feel there's something missing in the gameplay as it is now.
[close]
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (VOTING)
Post by: Stupot on Sun 15/12/2024 02:47:50
Thanks for the votes so far. If you haven't voted yet, it wouldn't be exaggerating to say the votes are currently very close at the moment, so every vote really will make a difference.



A bit of housekeeping...

If any MAGS game you have made in 2024 is not yet in the AGS database, be sure to add it by the end of December in order for it to be eligible for The AGS Awards. You can add your game here:
https://www.adventuregamestudio.co.uk/site/games/add/

NOTE: Any game that has won a monthly MAGS contest, is automatically eligible for MAGGIES (best of the best vote), but will not be eligible for the main AGS Awards if it is not in the database by the end of the year.
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (VOTING)
Post by: RootBound on Fri 27/12/2024 23:42:07
Looks like the results are in! Thanks for the votes that came my way, I really appreciate it.  (nod) And congratulations to @Babar and @jfrisby for a well deserved win and a REALLY memorable game. Looking forward to whatever is next from @jwalt too. I'm thrilled to have been a contender this time around. :)
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (VOTING)
Post by: Babar on Sat 28/12/2024 11:53:35
Wow, that was pretty close. Thanks Root!
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (VOTING)
Post by: jfrisby on Sat 28/12/2024 15:18:09
Thanks Rootbound, and thanks for voting and playing everyone!  :D
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (RESULT)
Post by: Stupot on Sat 28/12/2024 16:05:39
Well done again to Big Babs and J-Fro. You get to set the theme for January and kick off the new year.

Let's try to make 2025 'The year of MAGS'.

Thanks to the other entrants and voters.
Title: Re: MAGS November “Body of Water” (RESULT)
Post by: WHAM on Sat 04/01/2025 22:40:48
I didn't make it in time before voting this time, but I've still played all of the contestants. You can find the videos of my attempts below.

Bad to the Coral
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ThUlS3EN6gE

Botos do Diabo
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4VQLdGkUQBc

Gill Bus Party
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BXX9kLzSAtM