Adventure Game Studio

Creative Production => Critics' Lounge => Topic started by: Mouth for war on Tue 27/02/2007 17:57:21

Title: A bedroom
Post by: Mouth for war on Tue 27/02/2007 17:57:21
Here's a bedroom I just made, should there be anything more added to it...what do you think?

http://www.2dadventure.com/ags/bedroom1.PNG
Title: Re: A bedroom
Post by: Nikolas on Tue 27/02/2007 18:02:52
I think that you need to really really learn the tags in this forum. If you add [ img ] to the begining of the link and [ /img] to the end (without any spaces), it will show in the forum. Since it takes little space (being png), there is no reason not to do that.

(http://www.2dadventure.com/ags/bedroom1.PNG)

As for critic, your style if very clean and established, but I always find that I'm missing the shadows in your BGs (which otherwise are lovely). Additionally the door does seem somewhat strange, although it is a comic style, you've not showing it anywhere else (nor in the previous BGs, afak), so it is kind of irrelavent. The rest is quite lovley I believe. :)
Title: Re: A bedroom
Post by: Mouth for war on Tue 27/02/2007 18:08:03
ah yes the door needs work...you're absolutely right
Title: Re: A bedroom
Post by: Tuomas on Tue 27/02/2007 18:09:49
I don't quite agree with Nik on the door. But what strikes me, the room seems very big for a bedroom. And as one, it seems, that everything is on the side of the room, except for theleft side, which is completely empty. The room needs some balance, I'd say.
Title: Re: A bedroom
Post by: Mouth for war on Tue 27/02/2007 18:12:35
hmm well yes now that you mention it...it seems quite big hehe...I'll try and shrink it a little ;) BTW. I really suck at shadows that's why there are extremely few
Title: Re: A bedroom
Post by: Neil Dnuma on Wed 28/02/2007 16:35:13
The style reminds me of Donald Duck comics, but here - as in other BG's you've made - the furniture seems a bit tossed together, walls/doors seems rushed, and perspectives doesn't match. Also, the character could have been more in the same style - he seems a bit stiff for this world.

Are you using any kind of free comic resources? Or are you tracing comics?
Title: Re: A bedroom
Post by: Chicky on Thu 01/03/2007 11:09:37
Your art has always reminded me of comic trace overs, i'm not sure what it is. There's a lack of consistency in your backgrounds.