unfair bannings by AGS IRC ops

Started by deletethisprofile, Sat 06/01/2007 03:40:13

Previous topic - Next topic

deletethisprofile

Spleen and Hajo, who are ops of the AGS IRC channel who, in the last week have made unfair bannings of AGS members.
these members are:

John: banned by Hajo, for no good reason...
Pcj: banned by Spleen, a silly joke for simply not replying to Spleen

and Pmdee(who is me): I was banned (and right now still am evn though I've requested for an unban from Spleen and explained how stupid this is) for no good reason... I was also banned by Hajo, earlier in the week, I believe.  for the same reason...

I think this is completely stupid and immature of the ops and I am simply complaining here so it MAY be taken more seriously...

Renal Shutdown

#1
pcj: Banned by spleen, as a silly joke but unbanned moments later.Ã,  I don't think he even noticed.

Obviously, from seeing the pcj banning and subsequent unbanning, you know I'm not even partly sincere, in such actions.  Failing that, you should have gathered that from the PM's we exchanged.

John and Tuomas are banned for reasons out of my control, so I'm not going to comment on thir situations.
"Don't get defensive, since you have nothing with which to defend yourself." - DaveGilbert

deletethisprofile

but still, why should this even happen?Ã,  I'm sure there are some AGS members who agree with me, one AGS member (I won't mention his/her name) he/she also complained to AGS ops about this absolute immaturity and stupidity

Renal Shutdown

I suggest you look up the following words in a dictionary.

Joke.
Humour.
Laugh.

..and all their derivitives.

Have you ever told a joke? Have you ever said something funny?  Have you ever laughed at someone's misfortune, no matter how small?

Someone's been on the receiving end of that humour at some point.  This time it's you.  Get over yourself.
"Don't get defensive, since you have nothing with which to defend yourself." - DaveGilbert

deletethisprofile

#4
well, I am merely speaking for John, Tuomas, and myself.
I don't see this as funny at all...

(I am unbanned now, for which I am greatful for, although, I still find this nothing to laugh about) and ofcourse, neither do some other AGS members who have been banned for silly reasons...

Renal Shutdown

#5
You were the only one banned for a silly reason, and you were shortly thereafter unbanned.

Tuomas and John weren't banned for silly reasons.

EDIT:

Assuming someone was banned for a legitimate reason, making a whiny topic about it would not get them unbanned.Ã,  It would just get them banned and labelled as whiny.

EDIT:

Some folk found it funny.

[04:09] <spleen> it's pmdee. his discomfort is our hilarity.
[04:09] <********> it was pretty funny
"Don't get defensive, since you have nothing with which to defend yourself." - DaveGilbert

dasjoe

Quote from: http://www.adventuregamestudio.co.uk/acirc.htm
If you receive a ban, but feel it was unjust, take it up privately with the Op who banned you. Do not whine about it on the forums or other IRC channels.
Only the Op who created the ban may remove it. If the Op who banned you has been absent from the channel for a significant time (over 1 week), then you may request that another Op review your case.

other than that i can say for myself that i've had a genuine, valid reason for banning you
... it's quite easy being the best.

deletethisprofile

Hajo: when I came into AGS IRC one day, can't remeber the exact date. you asked me "YES or NO" I said no, because I knew it would be something silly, you then said something like "oh well, you don't have a choice. bye!"
and then I got banned from the channel, I wouldn't exactly call that a valid reason...  :-\

R4L

Why should anyone be banned from the AGS IRC? You obviously don't use the same policy as the forums, but I don't get why anyone would be banned from the IRC. I guess everyone has their reasons.

vict0r

Yeah... Unless someone are really spamming the irc, or being a complete jerk to everyone, I don't see why anyone would be banned. I can really see why Pmdee's annoyed here.

QuoteJoke.
Humour.
Laugh.

Have you ever told a joke? Have you ever said something funny?  Have you ever laughed at someone's misfortune, no matter how small?

Someone's been on the receiving end of that humour at some point.  This time it's you.  Get over yourself.

How old are you? 12? :-\


Ubel

The Vict0r and R4L, you guys never visit the IRC channel (at least not from what I've seen) so how would you know? Really, some people do get so annoying it's not surprising they get banned. I'm not pointing a finger at anyone though.

Tuomas

Please don't speak on my behalf. Banning me was completely deserved, and I have nothing against them :D Nevertheless, I was expecting for this to happen, you getting banned that is, makes me smile to think of it.

Frankly I don't remember why I was banned, but it was about time, I guess. So I'm not complaining. Note this right now, I'm not complaining ;)

Besides, if you're unbanned, what's the big deal?

vict0r

QuoteReally, some people do get so annoying it's not surprising they get banned

QuoteUnless someone are really spamming the irc, or being a complete jerk to everyone, I don't see why anyone would be banned

You are right, I never visits the channel, but I never claimed to either. But as far as I know, Pmdee never did anything. Noone even argued against the fact that he never did anything. Except hajo, but that was so diffuse that for me, it didn't really go as a valig argument.
And Pmdee explained what happened here too.

I agree with you that someone being annoying, or spamming should be temporarily banned, but here, I only see Pmdees point of view. And it seems pretty frustrating.




ManicMatt

#13
Quote from: Paul "Pmdee" Duggan on Sat 06/01/2007 03:58:03
one AGS member (I won't mention his/her name) he/she also complained to AGS ops about this absolute immaturity and stupidity

That is probably me? I was banned for one night because I didn't want to go bed when Hajo told me to, when I was a bit drunk that night, but I wasn't flaming or spamming. Yep, I got banned for not wanting to go to bed! (And then sent him a PM that contains the excerpt on Hajo's signature)

Then when I was done moaning about that, I asked Hajo to give me a justifiable reason as to why Pmdee was banned. He gave me unjustifiable reasons, to put it nicely. So I moaned to AGA I think it was, but Hajo just happened to be in the same room and read it! Then Pmdee was unbanned. Then Hajo told me I should have came to him first.  ::)

Tuomas, I think you got banned when you were presumably really drunk and was hurling abuse at no one in specific. (PM me if you really want to know what you said haha...)

Tuomas

Quote from: ManicMatt on Sat 06/01/2007 11:10:26
Tuomas, I think you got banned when you were presumably really drunk and was hurling abuse at no one in specific. (PM me if you really want to know what you said haha...)

That sounds like it could be very true. I can be really annoying, and I don't have to get drunk for it, but such happens.  ;D

dasjoe

Quote from: ManicMatt on Sat 06/01/2007 11:10:26
That is probably me? I was banned for one night because I didn't want to go bed when Hajo told me to, when I was a bit drunk that night, but I wasn't flaming or spamming. Yep, I got banned for not wanting to go to bed!
just to show people what actually happened:

Dez 04 03:33:28 <ManicMatt>   but that alcohol was stronger than anything i have b4
Dez 04 03:33:45 <ManicMatt>   like 3X vodka
Dez 04 03:33:58 <ManicMatt>   oooooooooooh vbed yes great is hould do that
Dez 04 03:34:43 <ManicMatt>   im gonn NEED A WAter cooler in the morning ;)

Dez 04 03:39:01 <ManicMatt>   YESH!!!!!! I never have puked from drink
Dez 04 03:39:19 <Zoot>   congratulations
Dez 04 03:39:28 <Zoot>   you must have only been to mediocre parties
Dez 04 03:39:34 <ManicMatt>   i dont get hangovers, see
Dez 04 03:39:37 <Jake>   Well to be fair, I puked because I drank 3 pints of cider in 3 mouthfuls in 6 seconds
Dez 04 03:39:44 <ManicMatt>   ah
Dez 04 03:40:20 <ManicMatt>   and dont say i wasnt drinking wnough, i been to the point of needing people to pull me up and jjjjjjjjjjyyeah

Dez 04 03:40:53 <ManicMatt>   i'll just be thirsty in morning
Dez 04 03:41:14 <ManicMatt>   where has the c key gone? ah yes here it is! hahahahahahahahhhhhhhh
Dez 04 03:41:19 <Jake>   Im thinking the first one.
Dez 04 03:41:38 <Zoot>   Hajo, you kicked me when I was drunk
Dez 04 03:41:55 <Hajo>   i think i get you ;)
Dez 04 03:42:04 <ManicMatt>   my teddy bear is on his back,poor thing
Dez 04 03:42:13 <Jake>   You only didn't kick me because you weren't here

Dez 04 03:43:25 <ManicMatt>   walking around is more fun when drunk than just sitting
Dez 04 03:43:42 <ManicMatt>   i sa walking........

Dez 04 03:46:37 <ManicMatt>   ow fell off chair
Dez 04 03:46:40 <ManicMatt>   back
Dez 04 03:46:53 <Zoot>   Hajo please.
Dez 04 03:47:02 <ManicMatt>   bastard
Dez 04 03:47:23 <ManicMatt>   yeah silver block fantastic
Dez 04 03:47:31 <ManicMatt>   point taken sheesh

Dez 04 03:47:57 <Hajo>   also, ManicMatt: go to sleep
Dez 04 03:48:21 <Jake>   Also, my old PC window had guybrush engraved on it :D :D
Dez 04 03:48:46 <ManicMatt>   oh yeahhhhhhhh people are annoying when theyre drunk its only fun for drunk person
Dez 04 03:49:33 <ManicMatt>   teeddy bear tells me to go bed now
Dez 04 03:49:42 <Hajo>   well, night
Dez 04 03:49:48 <Hajo>   rog remind me in 8 hours unban ManicMatt

Dez 04 03:50:53 ---   Hajo sets ban on *!*@*.lei3.cable.ntl.com
[...]
Dez 04 03:51:28 <Hajo>   oh right, forgot something :P
Dez 04 03:51:32 <Hajo>   night matt
Dez 04 03:51:37 <--   Hajo has kicked ManicMatt from #AGS (Hajo)


i then received this by you:
Quote from: ManicMatt
BAN??

What the fuck man?

So Im drunk? So fucking what?

I think the power has gone to your head, idiot.

Fuck you

so please stop lying about how nice you are and how unfair i treated you, Matt. you didn't even bother excusing yourself for being highly offensive towards me in that pm.
by the way: it's common practice to kickban annoying drunks for some hours, at least when i'm around and people complain. i really couldn't care less if you're not ok with that :)

now stop the whining and talk to the guys you've got problems with directly. and read the rules: http://www.adventuregamestudio.co.uk/acirc.htm
... it's quite easy being the best.

vict0r

I could understand your ban, if you had actually warned him. As far as I can see noone asked him to calm down, or be quiet. In fact it looks more like you encouraged him, or simply ignored him.. No matter how stupid Matt acted here, you acted wrong IMO.

ManicMatt

#17
Oh yes! My bad, I did say I was going to bed (albeit via my... erm.. teddy bear, apparently.) but you banned me when I was going anyway?

Alright then, very drunk, but as Vict0r says, you just kicked me off without any warning. And being drunk I got mad easily.

I like how this excerpt of irc cannot show any history between me and Hajo, that this was the first time anyone said anything bad.  ::)

Tuomas


vict0r

Oh! Yeah! What is it good for? Absolutely NOTHING!

SMF spam blocked by CleanTalk