Topic: The "Black Stories" crime riddles thread

[Mandle]

Case#58: Killed By Love

She was killed by those she loved the most. What happened?

YES
Was she a human?
Was she killed deliberately? (As with the "by accident" answer below this one is borderline, but yes)
Was she killed by a decision she made herself? (Kind of unavoidably, and not knowingly, but yes)
Was she in the proximity of those she loved the most when she died?
Was she elderly?
Was there any blood at the scene?
Was she killed suddenly (rather than slowly over time)?
Were those she loved the most her pet(s)?
Were "those she loved the most" living things?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of canine?
Did she die because of the wounds bleeding?
Did her dog(s) attack her?
Did her dog(s) not recognise her for some reason? (Not exactly but something like this, yes)
Did she startle her dog(s)? (More "scare" than "startle", but close enough)

NO
Was "she" a pet?
Was she diabetic but had a sweet tooth?
Did she love someone or something she was allergic to?
Was she murdered by accident? (Hmmm...Not exactly "by accident")
Was she killed by a relative?
Did she die in a hospital?
Did she die due to the administration of medication?
Did she die due to the non-administration of medication?
Was she a child?
Would this event constitute murder?
Did she choke on something?
Was she lying on her back? (Possibly, but doesn't really matter)
Is there a murder weapon near her body?
Was she found dead by the police?
Were those who killed her human?
Did she want to die?
Had she fallen unconscious before she was killed?
Were "those she loved the most" memories?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of feline?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of primate?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of marine life?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of reptile?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of lizard?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of insect?
Did the dog jump on her to lick her face and made her fall and hit her head?
Were those she loved the most a part of her?
Were those she loved the most called Jim, Jack or Johnny?
Were those she loved the most her cat(s)?
Did she choke on furballs?
Has she been poisoned?
Has she been strangled?
did she smell like dogfood?
Did she bathe in doogfood or meat?
Is she lady gaga wearing her meatdress again?

[selmiak]

Did she cosplay as catwoman and her dogs got angry?
Did she buy the wrong food and the dogs were very afraid because they had the same food over and over.
Did she normally feed them human flesh and this time brought normal dry food and the hunger remained...? Then this riddle should be rather about where she got the human flesh before though...

[Tabata]

Has she irritated the dogs by changing her look?
Did she do something that made the dogs biting her?
Did she say something that made the dogs attack her?

[Mandle]

Case#58: Killed By Love

She was killed by those she loved the most. What happened?

YES
Was she a human?
Was she killed deliberately? (As with the "by accident" answer below this one is borderline, but yes)
Was she killed by a decision she made herself? (Kind of unavoidably, and not knowingly, but yes)
Was she in the proximity of those she loved the most when she died?
Was she elderly?
Was there any blood at the scene?
Was she killed suddenly (rather than slowly over time)?
Were those she loved the most her pet(s)?
Were "those she loved the most" living things?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of canine?
Did she die because of the wounds bleeding?
Did her dog(s) attack her?
Did her dog(s) not recognise her for some reason? (Not exactly but something like this, yes)
Did she startle her dog(s)? (More "scare" than "startle", but close enough)
Has she irritated the dogs by changing her look? (Something about her was different, yes)

NO

Spoiler: ShowHide

Was "she" a pet?
Was she diabetic but had a sweet tooth?
Did she love someone or something she was allergic to?
Was she murdered by accident? (Hmmm...Not exactly "by accident")
Was she killed by a relative?
Did she die in a hospital?
Did she die due to the administration of medication?
Did she die due to the non-administration of medication?
Was she a child?
Would this event constitute murder?
Did she choke on something?
Was she lying on her back? (Possibly, but doesn't really matter)
Is there a murder weapon near her body?
Was she found dead by the police?
Were those who killed her human?
Did she want to die?
Had she fallen unconscious before she was killed?
Were "those she loved the most" memories?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of feline?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of primate?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of marine life?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of reptile?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of lizard?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of insect?
Did the dog jump on her to lick her face and made her fall and hit her head?
Were those she loved the most a part of her?
Were those she loved the most called Jim, Jack or Johnny?
Were those she loved the most her cat(s)?
Did she choke on furballs?
Has she been poisoned?
Has she been strangled?
did she smell like dogfood?
Did she bathe in doogfood or meat?
Is she lady gaga wearing her meatdress again?

Did she do something that made the dogs biting her? (No, apart from the action that changed her appearance)
Did she say something that made the dogs attack her?
Did she cosplay as catwoman and her dogs got angry?
Did she buy the wrong food and the dogs were very afraid because they had the same food over and over.
Did she normally feed them human flesh and this time brought normal dry food and the hunger remained...?

[Mandle]

I'll just also add here that this case is based on a true story I heard about on the news a few years ago which was so sad I have never forgotten about it.

I say this so people don't have to go through all the "Had she turned into a werewolf?" type questions to determine what about her appearance had changed.

Hehe... you guys are out of practice. I remember back in the day one of the first questions asked was usually "Could this case happen in real life?"

[Stupot]

Had she fainted or been knocked out.
Did the dogs think she was dead.
Did the dogs eat her alive?

[Mandle]

Case#58: Killed By Love

She was killed by those she loved the most. What happened?

YES
Was she a human?
Was she killed deliberately? (As with the "by accident" answer below this one is borderline, but yes)
Was she killed by a decision she made herself? (Kind of unavoidably, and not knowingly, but yes)
Was she in the proximity of those she loved the most when she died?
Was she elderly?
Was there any blood at the scene?
Was she killed suddenly (rather than slowly over time)?
Were those she loved the most her pet(s)?
Were "those she loved the most" living things?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of canine?
Did she die because of the wounds bleeding?
Did her dog(s) attack her?
Did her dog(s) not recognise her for some reason? (Not exactly but something like this, yes)
Did she startle her dog(s)? (More "scare" than "startle", but close enough)
Has she irritated the dogs by changing her look? (Something about her was different, yes)

NO

Spoiler: ShowHide

Was "she" a pet?
Was she diabetic but had a sweet tooth?
Did she love someone or something she was allergic to?
Was she murdered by accident? (Hmmm...Not exactly "by accident")
Was she killed by a relative?
Did she die in a hospital?
Did she die due to the administration of medication?
Did she die due to the non-administration of medication?
Was she a child?
Would this event constitute murder?
Did she choke on something?
Was she lying on her back? (Possibly, but doesn't really matter)
Is there a murder weapon near her body?
Was she found dead by the police?
Were those who killed her human?
Did she want to die?
Had she fallen unconscious before she was killed?
Were "those she loved the most" memories?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of feline?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of primate?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of marine life?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of reptile?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of lizard?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of insect?
Did the dog jump on her to lick her face and made her fall and hit her head?
Were those she loved the most a part of her?
Were those she loved the most called Jim, Jack or Johnny?
Were those she loved the most her cat(s)?
Did she choke on furballs?
Has she been poisoned?
Has she been strangled?
did she smell like dogfood?
Did she bathe in doogfood or meat?
Is she lady gaga wearing her meatdress again?

Did she do something that made the dogs biting her? (No, apart from the action that changed her appearance)
Did she say something that made the dogs attack her?
Did she cosplay as catwoman and her dogs got angry?
Did she buy the wrong food and the dogs were very afraid because they had the same food over and over.
Did she normally feed them human flesh and this time brought normal dry food and the hunger remained...?
Had she fainted or been knocked out?
Did the dogs think she was dead?
Did the dogs eat her alive? (They killed her but they didn't eat her)

[CaptainD]

Did she have a sex change and her dogs thought she was an intruder?

[Mandle]

Did she have a sex change and her dogs thought she was an intruder?

No, and just to save everyone a load of questions like "Had she had plastic/reconstructive surgery?": It wasn't her own personal physical appearance that was different that day. It wasn't any part of her body which was different.

[CaptainD]

Did she smell different?
Was she wearing some kind of device that gave off a sound that drove the dogs crazy? 
Did her voice sound different?

[Snarky]

Was she dressed differently from normal?

[Mandle]

Case#58: Killed By Love

She was killed by those she loved the most. What happened?

YES
Was she a human?
Was she killed deliberately? (As with the "by accident" answer below this one is borderline, but yes)
Was she killed by a decision she made herself? (Kind of unavoidably, and not knowingly, but yes)
Was she in the proximity of those she loved the most when she died?
Was she elderly?
Was there any blood at the scene?
Was she killed suddenly (rather than slowly over time)?
Were those she loved the most her pet(s)?
Were "those she loved the most" living things?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of canine?
Did she die because of the wounds bleeding?
Did her dog(s) attack her?
Did her dog(s) not recognise her for some reason? (Not exactly but something like this, yes)
Did she startle her dog(s)? (More "scare" than "startle", but close enough)
Has she irritated the dogs by changing her look? (Something about her was different, yes)

NO

Spoiler: ShowHide

Was "she" a pet?
Was she diabetic but had a sweet tooth?
Did she love someone or something she was allergic to?
Was she murdered by accident? (Hmmm...Not exactly "by accident")
Was she killed by a relative?
Did she die in a hospital?
Did she die due to the administration of medication?
Did she die due to the non-administration of medication?
Was she a child?
Would this event constitute murder?
Did she choke on something?
Was she lying on her back? (Possibly, but doesn't really matter)
Is there a murder weapon near her body?
Was she found dead by the police?
Were those who killed her human?
Did she want to die?
Had she fallen unconscious before she was killed?
Were "those she loved the most" memories?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of feline?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of primate?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of marine life?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of reptile?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of lizard?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of insect?
Did the dog jump on her to lick her face and made her fall and hit her head?
Were those she loved the most a part of her?
Were those she loved the most called Jim, Jack or Johnny?
Were those she loved the most her cat(s)?
Did she choke on furballs?
Has she been poisoned?
Has she been strangled?
did she smell like dogfood?
Did she bathe in doogfood or meat?
Is she lady gaga wearing her meatdress again?

Did she do something that made the dogs biting her? (No, apart from the action that changed her appearance)
Did she say something that made the dogs attack her?
Did she cosplay as catwoman and her dogs got angry?
Did she buy the wrong food and the dogs were very afraid because they had the same food over and over.
Did she normally feed them human flesh and this time brought normal dry food and the hunger remained...?
Had she fainted or been knocked out?
Did the dogs think she was dead?
Did the dogs eat her alive? (They killed her but they didn't eat her)
Did she have a sex change and her dogs thought she was an intruder?
Did she smell different?
Was she wearing some kind of device that gave off a sound that drove the dogs crazy?
Did her voice sound different?
Was she dressed differently from normal? (No, it wasn't her clothes or anything worn on the body)

[Stupot]

Had something grown on the woman?
Did she have a different hairstyle?
Did she have a beard?

[Snarky]

Were they in a different location than normal?
Did something else scare the dogs, preventing them from recognizing her?
Did the dogs perceive her to be attacking them?

[Mandle]

Case#58: Killed By Love

She was killed by those she loved the most. What happened?

YES
Was she a human?
Was she killed deliberately? (As with the "by accident" answer below this one is borderline, but yes)
Was she killed by a decision she made herself? (Kind of unavoidably, and not knowingly, but yes)
Was she in the proximity of those she loved the most when she died?
Was she elderly?
Was there any blood at the scene?
Was she killed suddenly (rather than slowly over time)?
Were those she loved the most her pet(s)?
Were "those she loved the most" living things?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of canine?
Did she die because of the wounds bleeding?
Did her dog(s) attack her?
Did her dog(s) not recognise her for some reason? (Not exactly but something like this, yes)
Did she startle her dog(s)? (More "scare" than "startle", but close enough)
Has she irritated the dogs by changing her look? (Something about her was different, yes)
Did the dogs perceive her to be attacking them? (Or about to attack, yes)

NO

Spoiler: ShowHide

Was "she" a pet?
Was she diabetic but had a sweet tooth?
Did she love someone or something she was allergic to?
Was she murdered by accident? (Hmmm...Not exactly "by accident")
Was she killed by a relative?
Did she die in a hospital?
Did she die due to the administration of medication?
Did she die due to the non-administration of medication?
Was she a child?
Would this event constitute murder?
Did she choke on something?
Was she lying on her back? (Possibly, but doesn't really matter)
Is there a murder weapon near her body?
Was she found dead by the police?
Were those who killed her human?
Did she want to die?
Had she fallen unconscious before she was killed?
Were "those she loved the most" memories?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of feline?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of primate?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of marine life?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of reptile?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of lizard?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of insect?
Did the dog jump on her to lick her face and made her fall and hit her head?
Were those she loved the most a part of her?
Were those she loved the most called Jim, Jack or Johnny?
Were those she loved the most her cat(s)?
Did she choke on furballs?
Has she been poisoned?
Has she been strangled?
did she smell like dogfood?
Did she bathe in doogfood or meat?
Is she lady gaga wearing her meatdress again?

Did she do something that made the dogs biting her? (No, apart from the action that changed her appearance)
Did she say something that made the dogs attack her?
Did she cosplay as catwoman and her dogs got angry?
Did she buy the wrong food and the dogs were very afraid because they had the same food over and over.
Did she normally feed them human flesh and this time brought normal dry food and the hunger remained...?
Had she fainted or been knocked out?
Did the dogs think she was dead?
Did the dogs eat her alive? (They killed her but they didn't eat her)
Did she have a sex change and her dogs thought she was an intruder?
Did she smell different?
Was she wearing some kind of device that gave off a sound that drove the dogs crazy?
Did her voice sound different?
Was she dressed differently from normal? (No, it wasn't her clothes or anything worn on the body)
Had something grown on the woman?
Did she have a different hairstyle?
Did she have a beard?
Were they in a different location than normal?
Did something else scare the dogs, preventing them from recognizing her?

[Snarky]

Was the change in appearance a matter of how she acted?
Did she suffer a medical emergency (stroke, epileptic fit...)?
Was she drugged or intoxicated?

[Tabata]

Has she had a beauty operation?
Did she wear a (beauty/oxygen)mask?
Did she have skin rash?

[dayowlron]

Was she sunburn?

[Cassiebsg]

Was her "change" an accident?
Was she wearing someone elses clothes?
Were the dogs wolfs?

[Mandle]

Case#58: Killed By Love

She was killed by those she loved the most. What happened?

YES
Was she a human?
Was she killed deliberately? (As with the "by accident" answer below this one is borderline, but yes)
Was she killed by a decision she made herself? (Kind of unavoidably, and not knowingly, but yes)
Was she in the proximity of those she loved the most when she died?
Was she elderly?
Was there any blood at the scene?
Was she killed suddenly (rather than slowly over time)?
Were those she loved the most her pet(s)?
Were "those she loved the most" living things?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of canine?
Did she die because of the wounds bleeding?
Did her dog(s) attack her?
Did her dog(s) not recognise her for some reason? (Not exactly but something like this, yes)
Did she startle her dog(s)? (More "scare" than "startle", but close enough)
Has she irritated the dogs by changing her look? (Something about her was different, yes)
Did the dogs perceive her to be attacking them? (Or about to attack, yes)
Did she suffer a medical emergency? (The day before, yes)
Was her "change" an accident? (Yes, she had had an accident)

NO

Spoiler: ShowHide

Was "she" a pet?
Was she diabetic but had a sweet tooth?
Did she love someone or something she was allergic to?
Was she murdered by accident? (Hmmm...Not exactly "by accident")
Was she killed by a relative?
Did she die in a hospital?
Did she die due to the administration of medication?
Did she die due to the non-administration of medication?
Was she a child?
Would this event constitute murder?
Did she choke on something?
Was she lying on her back? (Possibly, but doesn't really matter)
Is there a murder weapon near her body?
Was she found dead by the police?
Were those who killed her human?
Did she want to die?
Had she fallen unconscious before she was killed?
Were "those she loved the most" memories?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of feline?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of primate?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of marine life?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of reptile?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of lizard?
Were "those she loved the most" some kind of insect?
Did the dog jump on her to lick her face and made her fall and hit her head?
Were those she loved the most a part of her?
Were those she loved the most called Jim, Jack or Johnny?
Were those she loved the most her cat(s)?
Did she choke on furballs?
Has she been poisoned?
Has she been strangled?
did she smell like dogfood?
Did she bathe in doogfood or meat?
Is she lady gaga wearing her meatdress again?

Did she do something that made the dogs biting her? (No, apart from the action that changed her appearance)
Did she say something that made the dogs attack her?
Did she cosplay as catwoman and her dogs got angry?
Did she buy the wrong food and the dogs were very afraid because they had the same food over and over.
Did she normally feed them human flesh and this time brought normal dry food and the hunger remained...?
Had she fainted or been knocked out?
Did the dogs think she was dead?
Did the dogs eat her alive? (They killed her but they didn't eat her)
Did she have a sex change and her dogs thought she was an intruder?
Did she smell different?
Was she wearing some kind of device that gave off a sound that drove the dogs crazy?
Did her voice sound different?
Was she dressed differently from normal? (No, it wasn't her clothes or anything worn on the body)
Had something grown on the woman?
Did she have a different hairstyle?
Did she have a beard?
Were they in a different location than normal?
Did something else scare the dogs, preventing them from recognizing her?
Was the change in appearance a matter of how she acted?
Was she drugged or intoxicated?
Has she had a beauty operation?
Did she wear a (beauty/oxygen)mask?
Did she have skin rash?
Was she sunburn?
Was she wearing someone elses clothes?
Were the dogs wolfs?