310
edits
What's Wrong with Adventure Games: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
m
no edit summary
*>Dasjoe |
mNo edit summary |
||
| (3 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 74: | Line 74: | ||
Both in AGS and commercial games, characters aren't always done very well. It doesn't matter if it's humourous, serious, or somewhere in between, it's important to have characters with an intereting personality, preferably with some special twist to it. Character devlopment is also nice, though not neccessary IMO. | Both in AGS and commercial games, characters aren't always done very well. It doesn't matter if it's humourous, serious, or somewhere in between, it's important to have characters with an intereting personality, preferably with some special twist to it. Character devlopment is also nice, though not neccessary IMO. | ||
Umm, in | Umm, in commercial games, I'd like to see better voice acting, which is ussually not great. TLJ and GF have splendid voice acting for example. Though some would disagree, I'd also like to see voice acting in AGS games more, though I know it can be hard, since it's important that it's good. If it is good though, it adds so much IMO. Plus, I find myself reading the text and missing the talking animation, with voices I can look at the animation instead. Also, talking animations should be made more interesting than just moving the mouth, it should have something more to it, like head movements and hands possible. Or like Stan in MI, who moved his whole body while speaking. It added a whole lot of personality to him. | ||
(Is this some sort of official discussion always started after Mittens, each time a new topic?) | (Is this some sort of official discussion always started after Mittens, each time a new topic?) | ||
| Line 267: | Line 267: | ||
==Ginny Discussion== | ==Ginny Discussion== | ||
GG: Your point is very well presented, but since I havn't played PQ, I'm interested in exactly how the duties were performed. | |||
Your point is very well presented, but since I havn't played PQ, I'm interested in exactly how the duties were performed. | |||
If, for example, you had to find an armed criminal in hiding, disram him and arrest him, what was the proccess? Were the little bits like finding him for example include things like dialog puzzles or to trap him for example, would you pick up a net and put it on the ground? | If, for example, you had to find an armed criminal in hiding, disram him and arrest him, what was the proccess? Were the little bits like finding him for example include things like dialog puzzles or to trap him for example, would you pick up a net and put it on the ground? | ||
If yes, then it still could be called normal puzzles, but very much in context, which all puzzles should be. | If yes, then it still could be called normal puzzles, but very much in context, which all puzzles should be. | ||
| Line 286: | Line 285: | ||
Combining mouse and keyboard usage is annoying, that's for sure. | Combining mouse and keyboard usage is annoying, that's for sure. | ||
Barcik | {{Quote|author=Barcik|text=Getting stuck. I hate it when I sit 2 days, trying everything and clicking all that is in sight. You just have no darn clue what to do next. | ||
Obviously, there should be challenge, no doubt there. The solutions to puzzles mustn't be elementery. However, getting stuck takes away from your gaming experiencesas there is, unlike in other games with a wider array of options (such as GTA3, for example, where you can do anything), pretty much nothing to do if you do not progress the story. So, being stuck for long harms the gameplay and the link the player has established with the game.}} | |||
I agree, being stuck is a problem. If you don't get stuck at all, it might seem like the game is too easy, and the game would be much shorter if every puzzle would be solved immeadeatly, without some thought, IMO. | I agree, being stuck is a problem. If you don't get stuck at all, it might seem like the game is too easy, and the game would be much shorter if every puzzle would be solved immeadeatly, without some thought, IMO. | ||
However, this can be mended by making sure that when the player is stuck, he has more things to do. I don't mean other puzzles, because these too could, after being finished, leave you stuck with the one puzzle you can't solve. | However, this can be mended by making sure that when the player is stuck, he has more things to do. I don't mean other puzzles, because these too could, after being finished, leave you stuck with the one puzzle you can't solve. | ||
| Line 312: | Line 308: | ||
Is this an annual thing, starting a debate about something after Mittens? Like a sort of activity? {{Smiley}} | Is this an annual thing, starting a debate about something after Mittens? Like a sort of activity? {{Smiley}} | ||
[[Category:Game | [[Category:Adventure Game Design]] | ||