Adventure Game Studio

Creative Production => Critics' Lounge => Topic started by: DanClarke on Tue 11/10/2005 23:05:52

Title: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: DanClarke on Tue 11/10/2005 23:05:52
IK, i spent some time animating today, and something i noticed was that i'm not overly keen on the hat that Gloria wears, and it's also a humongous pain in the ass in terms of animating. Gloria comes from pretty much a present day period, so i don't think the hat is really fitting in that sense either. So i've come up with a new version of hers truly. I know some of you are going to prefer the old one, but i actually think he looks cuter with her hair down!:

(http://www.2dadventure.com/ags/girlfinalNEW.jpg)

P.S: I'm also toying with the idea of changing the shirt colour.

EDIT:

(http://www.2dadventure.com/ags/girlfinalNEW2.jpg)

EDIT 2:

(http://www.2dadventure.com/ags/girlfinalNEWpony.jpg)

EDIT 3:

(http://www.2dadventure.com/ags/girlfinalNEW2a.jpg)

tidied up the shirt + shorts, and moved her head back slightly, it appeared a little craned.
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: Scummbuddy on Tue 11/10/2005 23:10:21
Shes a total babe. :=

Erm.. well. I do like the hair down, and agree on dropping the hat... but then again, there should be something that identifies with her. Maybe not.

The white shirt, I think, works just fine.

She has gotten cuter. What did you do?Ã,  ;)
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: edmundito on Tue 11/10/2005 23:12:37
I like it. I think it give it a much nicer look. Maybe the hat can make a cameo somewhere in her room or something... ;)

Um, not to be picky, but the clothes remind me of Ben Jordan's old outfit... :D

Have you tried messing with a ponytail or a head band? Althogh I like this one, I always like to suggest some ideas. Perhaps the shirt color can be based on what kind of person gloria is, I don't know about the character as much as you do.

However, I always figured that she got the hat from soneone like her grandpa gave it to her or something. Kind of like uh... Link in Zelda: The Wind Waker.
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: DanClarke on Tue 11/10/2005 23:39:29
Lol ok guys, easy on the babe comments, we've decided on a final age, she's 14[/i].
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: Kweepa on Wed 12/10/2005 00:15:03
Her hair is a bit octagonal at the back.
I like the ponytail (edit 2)  - that could be because the octagonalness is minimised.
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: loominous on Wed 12/10/2005 00:28:39
Not what you asked for, but something that bothered me:

(http://marcus.krupa.se/AGS/tl_g.gif)

I always liked that hat. It's true that she looks cuter without it, but she looses much of her originality, and I find too cute/attractive protagonists a problem, similar to how flawless personalities usually equals boring.

That avatar you've got could work well as coverart in it's simplicity, which I think is a good indicator of a solid design. I doubt that these modified looks would suffice in that situation.

Since you seem unhappy with the old one I suggest that keep looking for a new design that has the good qualities of the original and as well as satisfy your new demands.
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: Shane 'ProgZmax' Stevens on Wed 12/10/2005 02:34:08
I made a few different versions (and cleaned up the sprite in case someone else wants to play with a non-blown up version).

(http://members.cox.net/progzmax/gloriastylez.gif)
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: Evil on Wed 12/10/2005 02:59:07
I loved that hat. :(

But if you must go with the pony tail then go with something like Prog's. It's much more girly, and much less "sexy" as the current style.
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: sergiocornaga on Wed 12/10/2005 04:51:22
Why not have various outfits? Your game would be viewed as truly professional.
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: ildu on Wed 12/10/2005 05:31:10
SergioCornaga: Most likely because the animations would be an even bigger pain in the butt.

I, too, loved the hat. It gave it a very original look. It also added kind of a Spirited Away fantasy feel to the whole game. Now she looks just too ordinary. And as someone said, it makes you wonder why she has such an odd hat that looks too large for her. It makes you think maybe her grandfather gave it to her, which then deepens the relationship and the whole story a lot.
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: Gregjazz on Wed 12/10/2005 07:39:51
I like hairstyle in edit 2 the best. Keep up the good work!
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: mätzyboy on Wed 12/10/2005 08:54:29
I agree with Evil that the hat added to her personality. But if the hat has to go, the hat has to go...

In that case edit nr. 2 with loominous changes in posture would be the best alternative in my opinion!
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: DanClarke on Wed 12/10/2005 11:13:26
Thanks for the feedbacl guys, i prefer the hair down tbh, but i'll keep going until i find something.

Prog: I like your edits (1 of them looks scarily like my g/f lol) but i think the styles might be a little too mature for a 14 year old.

Loominous: You're certainly right about the posture change and ill look into that, bar the legs in your edit, i think theyre a little too skinny.

I'll keep going until i find something that stands out a little more.
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: Snarky on Wed 12/10/2005 13:48:25
Oh man, without the hat I don't see any reason to play this game.  ;)

But seriously. The hat rocked. I will mourn its absence. Hey, maybe someone can provide a hatpatch to modify the sprites and restore the headgear!
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: DoorKnobHandle on Wed 12/10/2005 13:59:06
You have so many great looking sprites, it'd be a shame to have to go with only one.
If I'd be you, I would make her change her appearance several times in the game. That would make her a more believable character and it would show off all those great sprites. You could even go as far as having the way she looks dependent on the situation she is in. Do you have a scene where she has to act mature and grown-up? Then let her hair and the rest of her body seem more mature (like in prog's edit). Or does she seem immature, childish and young in a scene? Then let her wear that hat, that makes her look younger.
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: DanClarke on Wed 12/10/2005 15:09:50
Quote from: dkh on Wed 12/10/2005 13:59:06
You have so many great looking sprites, it'd be a shame to have to go with only one.
If I'd be you, I would make her change her appearance several times in the game. That would make her a more believable character and it would show off all those great sprites. You could even go as far as having the way she looks dependent on the situation she is in. Do you have a scene where she has to act mature and grown-up? Then let her hair and the rest of her body seem more mature (like in prog's edit). Or does she seem immature, childish and young in a scene? Then let her wear that hat, that makes her look younger.

It's an interesting idea, and a few people have mentioned it. As said, the workload for creating full animations with different clothing would be too much in  asingle game, but there's always part two, so i guess she can have a change of clothes for the 2nd part when it does eventually arise.
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: Nikolas on Wed 12/10/2005 18:50:32
Quote from: DanClarke on Wed 12/10/2005 15:09:50
It's an interesting idea, and a few people have mentioned it. As said, the workload for creating full animations with different clothing would be too much inÃ,  asingle game, but there's always part two, so i guess she can have a change of clothes for the 2nd part when it does eventually arise.

Well, there's always the possibility to get help for the animation part also. Actually while thinking about it, there are at least ten people who do animation once a week (I'm talking about the animation comp). I'm sure that someone (more than one actually) will want to help you.

Imagine that you, yourself, did 4 different versions! You must have time to do like another... [(2x8)x4]...64 different versions for an animated sprite with 8 positions for up, down etc...

Shit! That's a lot of workload. Find work!

Anyway check the animation competitions and then see... how it goes.

I can't believe that I'm here only 4 months and allready giving advice to a guy who is here 1 and a half year!  :-\
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: Darth Mandarb on Wed 12/10/2005 18:57:14
You know ... if just the colors of her shirt/pants were to change.  It would be a change of clothes and not require any re-animating, just color replacing.

I own 4 pair of shorts that are all the same, just different colors, and about 30 t-shirts like that.

Just a suggestion :)
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: Nikolas on Wed 12/10/2005 19:00:58
You know, I can imagine, a bunch of AGSers playing TLOTLL and wainting for her to take of her hat :'(, or change clothes and then applause and having tears in their eyes...

I think that here, you have very strong feelings from everyone to do this. To have different clothes (and maybe to keep her hat?)

Of course it is up to you, don't forget that. And either way it is great!
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: DanClarke on Wed 12/10/2005 19:18:05
Quote from: Nikolas on Wed 12/10/2005 18:50:32
Quote from: DanClarke on Wed 12/10/2005 15:09:50
It's an interesting idea, and a few people have mentioned it. As said, the workload for creating full animations with different clothing would be too much in  asingle game, but there's always part two, so i guess she can have a change of clothes for the 2nd part when it does eventually arise.

Well, there's always the possibility to get help for the animation part also. Actually while thinking about it, there are at least ten people who do animation once a week (I'm talking about the animation comp). I'm sure that someone (more than one actually) will want to help you.

Imagine that you, yourself, did 4 different versions! You must have time to do like another... [(2x8)x4]...64 different versions for an animated sprite with 8 positions for up, down etc...

Shit! That's a lot of workload. Find work!

Anyway check the animation competitions and then see... how it goes.

I can't believe that I'm here only 4 months and allready giving advice to a guy who is here 1 and a half year!  :-\

Ill look into the possibilty of her changing at some point, but im not gonna go ott with it, it doesnt really add anything to the game, and i dont want people to be distracted from the main game beause they spen an hour clicking 'use wardrobe'.
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: Tuomas on Wed 12/10/2005 20:32:58
If you ask me, I really love the 2nd edit with the ponytail... and the original white shirt... actually I loved the sprite with the hat also, so what else there is to say :) Add her a skirt though with the ponytail and she's sixteen...

And I also like the Prog.'s edit in which she has the shorter hair, she looks like my 13-year-old cousin :D :D How odd is that, she's exactly like her :D

But with changing clothes, don't bother, if I were you, I'd stick with the original, with the ponytail of course. Sometimes the orginal is the best... But this is just me
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: Mordalles on Wed 12/10/2005 22:45:10
edit 2 looks the best with the ponytail. i would go for that one.  ;)
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: on Thu 13/10/2005 18:34:37
you could create views with the hat at the positions it would have to be if she wore it, but without a character, and apply that view to an "invisible" character that overlaps her ?... someone said this could be done; I tried it but found that there always is a delay in the movement...

anyway, it's a great character. really. no strings attached, I like her and am waiting to see her in the game! keep that style up!
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: LGM on Thu 13/10/2005 22:49:26
I think they just want her to undress on screen.
Title: Re: *TLOTLL* Updated Gloria *see inside*
Post by: DanClarke on Fri 14/10/2005 01:03:03
Lol, i do hope you're wrong. I've been doing some work on my new website (should be running by tomorrow) and ive come up with this for those interested:

(http://www.2dadventure.com/ags/gloriasevolution.jpg)

It's an evolution of her from the very first picture i did of her on the left, right through the ages. As you can see, we've had allsorts, grotesque hunchback gloria, short-ugly nerd gloria, right upto the cute new hatless gloria. Action figures coming soon ;)