Adventure Game Studio

Creative Production => Critics' Lounge => Topic started by: Domino on Tue 18/05/2004 03:52:32

Title: 2 backgrounds for criticism, please be gentle
Post by: Domino on Tue 18/05/2004 03:52:32
(http://mysite.verizon.net/vze7xpq3/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/farm1.jpg)

(http://mysite.verizon.net/vze7xpq3/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/bg5.jpg)

I am seriously gonna work on a game this time, but these are the first 2 screenies i have of the game.Ã,  When i'm working on them, my mind goes blank and i don't know what else to do. I trust my AGS friends to help me improve these screens.

note: i haven't finished the second BG.  The windows i could not figure how to look right.
Title: Re: 2 backgrounds for criticism, please be gentle
Post by: Moox on Tue 18/05/2004 04:02:05
oww really bright, looks good, remove black outline on barn and grain silo
Title: Re: 2 backgrounds for criticism, please be gentle
Post by: LordHart on Tue 18/05/2004 04:22:59
Yeah, I have to agree that it is too bright. But maybe that is just because of the yellow, and then the pink chimney of the second pic. :-[
Title: Re: 2 backgrounds for criticism, please be gentle
Post by: LGM on Tue 18/05/2004 04:30:08
The brigtness reminds of of Richard Longhurst and the Box That Ate Time..

The barn looks acceptionally good.. And the rest works quite well.. tis a neat style you got going there
Title: Re: 2 backgrounds for criticism, please be gentle
Post by: MrColossal on Tue 18/05/2004 05:11:06
I love the brightness, it's so children's book

i enjoy it a lot and there isn't much i can comment on at the moment, i don't think
Title: Re: 2 backgrounds for criticism, please be gentle
Post by: Darth Mandarb on Tue 18/05/2004 05:25:49
The bright colors at first REALLY caught my attention ... but the more I look the more I like it.

The first one looks really good!Ã,  The layout is perfect and it just ... fits.Ã,  Great job on that one!Ã,  Some suggestions:
- the two middle roof lines (barn) appear to be slightly off perspective
- remove the black outline around the silo (as was mentioned)

The second one is good (not as good as the first one yet) but since it's still a WiP I won't comment too much.Ã,  The main thing I would say would be to shrink the flowers a little ... unless they're supposed to be overly-large!

Good work man!
Title: Re: 2 backgrounds for criticism, please be gentle
Post by: Phemar on Tue 18/05/2004 05:36:28

Add a shadow for the fence on 1st one, curve windows more...
Title: Re: 2 backgrounds for criticism, please be gentle
Post by: oscar on Tue 18/05/2004 06:47:48
Quote from: LilGryphMaster on Tue 18/05/2004 04:30:08
The brigtness reminds of of Richard Longhurst and the Box That Ate Time..

can't you guys stop saying "it reminds me of..." allt the time? it's getting annoying. please
Title: Re: 2 backgrounds for criticism, please be gentle
Post by: Peter Thomas on Tue 18/05/2004 07:31:32
That reminds me of a conversation we had in #ags once ;)

I like the pics. I especially like the large flowers. It reminds me - as eric said - of a children's book.
Title: Re: 2 backgrounds for criticism, please be gentle
Post by: Minimi on Tue 18/05/2004 08:43:38
This is awesome looking brightness! It reminds me of the VGA time, with extremely bright graphics! Looks good, keep the spirit alive!
Title: Re: 2 backgrounds for criticism, please be gentle
Post by: Dart on Tue 18/05/2004 11:38:14
Hehe... I love the barn.

So much, that...

*Dart steals barn image and uses it in her game*

Eh, nevermind. But what's this game supposed to be about?
Title: Re: 2 backgrounds for criticism, please be gentle
Post by: Andail on Tue 18/05/2004 11:43:58
It reminds me of mom's quest more than anything else, the naivistic and stylistic details, like those huge flowers, etc...

Especially the first bg is an ace
Title: Re: 2 backgrounds for criticism, please be gentle
Post by: on Tue 18/05/2004 13:01:40
Both backgrounds look good! Their bright nature isn't a problem at all. I don't think they need to be darkened because sometimes the colours of the land ARE that bright-style colour;

(http://screen7.adventuredevelopers.com/fun/lj_moodysky.jpg)
for example.

The backgrounds don't remind me of anything, but if I had to choose then the first one reminds me of Oklahoma and the second Richard Longhurst as others said. Both nice backgrounds and I think they'll look great in game, and the brightness won't be a problem.
Title: Re: 2 backgrounds for criticism, please be gentle
Post by: Ginny on Tue 18/05/2004 15:02:02
I really like the whole look of the first image, the layout is great as darth said. I like the small details you added, such as the sunflower, the tree stump, and the odd plant in the crop that looks like a pumpkin ;). Normally bright colours bug me, and I like low-saturation, but in this case it fits very well. Maybe just the yellow is a bit painful because unlike the photograph m0ds took, the yellow in your bg's 9second one more precisely) covers a large area.. Maybe not..
Anyway, the barn with it's bricks looks great, and the other house reminds me of (;)) some kind of fruit.. With the pink chimney thing that resembles a straw or something, and the green leaves at the top, it makes it look like it's located in "Fruit-house land" :D.
I would suggest not to save it as jpg, it adds artifacts, but if you're using mspaint, gif doesn't seem to work too well either. I'd use a different program to convert bmp to gif, or if you're not using paint, just save as gif.
The windows should probably be a somewhat lighter, paler blue.
There is something abou the size of the rooms that bugs me: what resolution will you be using? The first pic looks like it's a room for 320X200 res, but scrolling, but the second looks like it's 640X400. Maybe you just made the second pic bigger here on the forums.
edit: *checks link for images* Aha, so you have used 2x. Well, all the better :).
Title: Re: 2 backgrounds for criticism, please be gentle
Post by: Domino on Wed 19/05/2004 01:27:37
Thank you for all your kind words.Ã,  :)

I got the idea for nice bright backgrounds with alot of color after watching the Wizard of Oz again last week.Ã,  I just felt compelled to try and copy that, hence the yellow road, although not brick.

I think this is way i'm gonna go, and like most of you have already said, it does look like a kids book, and this was also the effect i was going after.

Thank you again. Now i'm going back to working on them.

Shawn

oh, isn't it funny that my name is Dark-of-Night, but i used the brightest colors in the world when doing backgrounds. I just found that kind of funny.