Adventure Game Studio

Creative Production => Critics' Lounge => Topic started by: TerranRich on Sat 17/10/2009 04:36:55

Title: Critique my game home page!
Post by: TerranRich on Sat 17/10/2009 04:36:55
So because I'm a web developer first and a game developer second, I've been working on the home page for my By the Sword series of games, partly as a portfolio piece, and partly as a legitimate home page for my games.

(http://img407.imageshack.us/img407/9012/bts2009websitev2.jpg)

What do you think? I've gone over this with a fine-tooth comb, altering details here and there, and I've come across the block where I can't find anything else on my own and would like outside help on this. What needs to be changed? Added? Taken out? Moved around? Shaken, but not stirred?

Thanks guys. :)
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: PixelPerfect on Sat 17/10/2009 15:16:31
From a short glance some feelings I had:

- I really like it!  :)
- Color scheme is good. Only thing worth more testing would be maybe to bring the light blue down from links just a bit to blend in more but still be easily detectable.
- Maybe swap the "Keep updated" and "See more posts" -boxes? Would seem more natural to me.
- If you want more space there for news text you could make the boxes on the right a little bit smaller.
- The "haze" effect in the main picture is a little bit overwhelming for my taste. Maybe take it down a notch.
- Overall very nice! I'd surely visit!

I'm on a crappy monitor right now so the color things may be off.  :)

Kudos for the nice design!
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: Chicky on Sat 17/10/2009 16:13:53
Looks very good, i like the character models as well! I don't think it needs a lot more, maybe an email box for a mailing list?
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: Shane 'ProgZmax' Stevens on Sat 17/10/2009 17:48:44
The robot guy looks like he's doing something to the girl's ass, but other than that I like it.  Maybe flip the robot guy and put him on the right side and the other dude in the middle?
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: TerranRich on Sat 17/10/2009 18:09:53
LOL. That's a good observation. Plus, the main character should be in the middle anyway. Thanks! Here's what I've got now:

(http://img26.imageshack.us/img26/9012/bts2009websitev2.jpg)
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: IndieBoy on Sat 17/10/2009 21:07:11
The main character guy looks like he's doing something to the robot's ass...
Only joking. Very nice and professional looking.
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: Anian on Sat 17/10/2009 22:52:58
Maybe the main character should be looking at the us (in front of him). Did you think about some more background except just the blue light(maybe some shot from the game like spaceships and some plantes etc.)?
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: TerranRich on Sat 17/10/2009 23:02:46
As the game progresses, I will be adding better header backgrounds with screenshots, collages of images, etc. And I'll try it out with Ron facing the viewer. It makes sense.
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: LGM on Sun 18/10/2009 16:14:57
When are your releasing this game?
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: TerranRich on Sun 18/10/2009 18:08:42
The first game should be out early 2010.

Here's the home page with Ron facing the viewer. Also, should I put a divider into the "Keep Updated" box like below? Or leave it the way it was?

(http://img9.imageshack.us/img9/9012/bts2009websitev2.jpg)
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: AngelicCharon on Sun 18/10/2009 20:30:02
I'm kind of with Anian here.

While it looks great, and 'professional' from a web design perspective...that blue light behind the characters is a smidge generic/dull, and seems to take away from the rest of it.  For me, it makes it feel like something's missing.

I think almost any sort of BG element may so better....I say this because of it's size.

If the header area was smaller, the empty space the blue blur is occupying wouldn't be as distracting.
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: TerranRich on Mon 19/10/2009 02:16:23
How is this? I used a collage of several backgrounds already done for the game, with an effect over them, and I solidified the characters.

(http://img25.imageshack.us/img25/9012/bts2009websitev2.jpg)
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: FSi++ on Mon 19/10/2009 09:17:35
Quote from: TerranRich on Sun 18/10/2009 18:08:42
Here's the home page with Ron facing the viewer. Also, should I put a divider into the "Keep Updated" box like below? Or leave it the way it was?

Looks better with the divider.
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: PixelPerfect on Mon 19/10/2009 19:19:55
Good progression! Gripes: The background is too detailed in relation to the characters. Here's a quick mockup:

(http://www.2dadventure.com/ags/bytheswordPP.png)

And I don't know about the "looking towards the user". I think it's kinda weird. But that's just me.
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: Anian on Mon 19/10/2009 22:52:12
Hmm, now that I've looked again, I think the problem might be that the main character is small and/or the same as the other two, except that he looks blander (hope I'm not getting into criticing your character design here), cause personally, from what I see here, I'd rather play as them than the charcter in the middle (they're kinda cooler and I actually think the girl's heads is larger than his, in any case they both draw more attention than the main character). I mean they have cool battle armour and a mask and the guy in the middle has a t-shirt...

On the composition part, maybe move the characters to one side and smaller...not really sure, IMO.
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: TerranRich on Tue 20/10/2009 05:53:12
Now you've got me worried that my main character might be too bland. I hope that won't be the general consensus when people play the game. My intention is to have him wear an off-duty type of outfit instead of his usual uniform, since the first game takes place on Earth. I suppose I could display him in the uniform he'll be wearing in the other two games.

How does it look now?

(http://img27.imageshack.us/img27/9012/bts2009websitev2.jpg)
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: kconan on Tue 20/10/2009 09:51:27
The page looks great overall, while it might be nitpicky my only input is to use less variety in your types of fonts.

I like the "keep it simple" menu on the top right.  Don't drop that.
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: Intense Degree on Tue 20/10/2009 10:19:32
The only thing that I would say is that the magnifying glass icon in the See More Posts box looks too big and too luminescent (if that's the right word ???). Otherwise it's looking good.
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: Shane 'ProgZmax' Stevens on Tue 20/10/2009 16:39:39
I completely disagree with PixelPerfect.  I really like the new backdrop WITHOUT the blur because now it's really distracting to see masses of over-softened pixels behind very clean characters.  I find that in the clean example my attention is naturally drawn to Ron while my eye wanders uncomfortably around the header when it's blurred.  

Also, what if Ron is looking up to the stars or something instead of at the viewer?  It's a bit creepy having a 3d face staring at you while you browse!  
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: PixelPerfect on Tue 20/10/2009 17:05:43
Yeah the latest isn't good, it's too blurry and the blur is a weird direction blur. If you do a blur, you should do a subtle lens blur to give the feel of an actual camera and space difference. The totally crisp one isn't bad, but I think it could be better. It competes too much with the characters, in my opinion.
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: TerranRich on Tue 20/10/2009 20:10:17
Thanks for all your suggestions, guys. I've fixed up the header background a bit, changing it to a lens blur and lowering its opacity, and changed Ron so he's not staring directly into your soul. The glow behind the magnifying glass was from before when several other elements had a glow behind them, so I fixed it to match the rest of the icons. I also set the wide font that was there before to the same font as the body text (Segoe UI). Let me know how it looks now.

(http://img15.imageshack.us/img15/9012/bts2009websitev2.jpg)
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: Shane 'ProgZmax' Stevens on Tue 20/10/2009 20:55:59
Looks good.  The blur doesn't make my eyes hurt now :).
Title: Re: Critique my game home page!
Post by: TerranRich on Wed 21/10/2009 06:00:51
I think I'll be going with this design then. Thank you everybody for your thoughts and suggestions!