Adventure Game Studio

Creative Production => Critics' Lounge => Topic started by: Neutron on Tue 19/10/2004 07:20:35

Title: Graveyard - BG
Post by: Neutron on Tue 19/10/2004 07:20:35
This is actually the background of an animation I'm working on, but I made a game size render in case I think of a use for it later on.  C and C?
(http://home.att.net/~yorik/graveyard1.png)
Title: Re: Graveyard - BG
Post by: Gilbert on Tue 19/10/2004 07:36:03
Nice, but my complain is that it's too dark (at least for this crap monitor here), maybe make the edges of the tombstones reflect more light "from the moon" can help defining their shapes.

Another thing is that yellow thingie looks more like a meteor than a moon, I think reducing the shadows on it may help.
Title: Re: Graveyard - BG
Post by: fovmester on Tue 19/10/2004 09:18:55
It's way too dark! Add some reflected light on the edges of things and it'll look better. I agree with Gilbot on the moon. Try to make it more solid looking. Otherwise I think it's a good background!
Title: Re: Graveyard - BG
Post by: Isegrim on Tue 19/10/2004 09:36:08
Maybe use volumetric lighting instead of the fog? Also, for my taste, the separation between land and sky is too sheer. Some sad trees in the background would help IMO...
Title: Re: Graveyard - BG
Post by: on Tue 19/10/2004 14:16:10
Hey great background!

I don't really think it's too dark, but the contrast moon / earth is a bit odd...

either you should make the moon less bright or the rest a little brighter. Try walking outside when the moon is full, you'll be amazed how much you really can see! A full moon gives a lot of light
Title: Re: Graveyard - BG
Post by: BorisZ on Tue 19/10/2004 15:36:24
No one has the right to comment Neutrons images (especialy beackgrounds) since no one of you ever got close to that quality (including me, off course)!
Title: Re: Graveyard - BG
Post by: Sam. on Tue 19/10/2004 17:20:22
um.. boris? if noone had the right to comment on them, why would he post here?

anyway, i like it, although it is not clear that the fog is... well fog. it looks like smushy ground.  trees and general foliage, or a fence would do well also
Title: Re: Graveyard - BG
Post by: BorisZ on Tue 19/10/2004 18:24:28
Quote from: Zooty on Tue 19/10/2004 17:20:22
um.. boris? if noone had the right to comment on them, why would he post here?

anyway, i like it, although it is not clear that the fog is... well fog. it looks like smushy ground.Ã,  trees and general foliage, or a fence would do well also

Can't you see I'm kidding. I just wanted to point Neutrons talent, wich we,  I guess, all respect.
I think that fog looks fine, by the way.
Title: Re: Graveyard - BG
Post by: Al_Ninio on Tue 19/10/2004 18:33:54
Quote from: BorisZ on Tue 19/10/2004 18:24:28
Quote from: Zooty on Tue 19/10/2004 17:20:22
um.. boris? if noone had the right to comment on them, why would he post here?

anyway, i like it, although it is not clear that the fog is... well fog. it looks like smushy ground.  trees and general foliage, or a fence would do well also

Can't you see I'm kidding. I just wanted to point Neutrons talent, wich we,  I guess, all respect.
I think that fog looks fine, by the way.

This is the critics lounge, not the praise lounge.

Anyway, to get on topic.
I think it is a fine background, except it is, as people have mentioned, way too dark.
I thought it was a render of a night-sky scene before looking at it in PS with the brightness level upped.
Title: Re: Graveyard - BG
Post by: Neutron on Tue 19/10/2004 22:16:30
Thanks for all the nice comments guys, I'll see if I can fix the lighting and the mist.  I kind of like the moon the way it is though, I could have made a more realistic one, but I like the glowing look.
Title: Re: Graveyard - BG
Post by: BorisZ on Tue 19/10/2004 22:55:49
Quote from: Highwaygal on Tue 19/10/2004 18:33:54
This is the critics lounge, not the praise lounge.

Ah, you are just jelous!