Disclaimer : We're discussing the rear view only.
So we have this first draft for the rear view (a big big thank you to Nr. 2698 and selmiak for the sprite they drew despite me fixing a few things here and there).
[imgzoom]https://68.media.tumblr.com/9d6985b8e5c320e7a8a87567934bdd6a/tumblr_oi5dugqaOM1tsfksfo2_75sq.png[/imgzoom]
3x:
[imgzoom]https://68.media.tumblr.com/ba745feec6f1a7fc0f559694745849c3/tumblr_oi5dugqaOM1tsfksfo1_250.png[/imgzoom]
How would you make it better?
For me personally, Nothing wrong over there Monsieur, at all. its a perfect flip from the front view all shading and lighting are well put in place. Awesome result.
Amelie made a great improvement; I've made more improvements on top of her work.
Which do you like most? A, B, C or D?
Look carefuly each image, to see what has changed.
[imgzoom]https://68.media.tumblr.com/563701c1270846b685bbaf8cb99f0832/tumblr_oi6cq0uvtl1tsfksfo1_250.gif[/imgzoom]
Personally I prefer B. But I don't trust my sense of judgement in these matters.
With A, your team artists crafted one very nice rear view. Maybe if Indy travels to a colder region, it would work quite well as a more warm bomber jacket.
D it is because it has all bells and whistles (subtle higher shoulder and better arm lighting). Also it works well together with C, maybe for an idle animation etc.
After changing my mind 4 times...I pick C
so any more votes guys? :)
Which do you like most? A, B, C or D?
Uhm... not A? (laugh) Does that help?
The other 3 just seem a slight positioning of the arm...
D has the best ellbow, but I don't like how the black pixels define his left arm
Quote from: selmiak on Sat 17/12/2016 14:44:32
D has the best ellbow, but I don't like how the black pixels define his left arm
You mean the shoulder articulation is too high for your taste?
yeah, these black pixels make it look like it's cut off, and sewn on again, could also be the leather jacket then...