Adventure Game Studio

Creative Production => Critics' Lounge => Topic started by: Moebius on Mon 16/01/2006 22:02:01

Title: Inside the spaceship & 3 Aliens
Post by: Moebius on Mon 16/01/2006 22:02:01
Hello everybody.

I just wrap paintin' the background up and I need some criticism.

(http://www.misniakiewicz.org/images/room.jpg)

Asaide from room background I was drew these guys:
[Captain of the spaceship]
(http://www.misniakiewicz.org/images/ufol.jpg)
[Ordinary worker]
(http://www.misniakiewicz.org/images/ufol1.jpg)
[Not ordinary worker]
(http://www.misniakiewicz.org/images/ufol2.jpg)
And here you are. Everybody in the spaceship:

http://www.misniakiewicz.org/images/roomall.jpg

What do you think about it? Criticize please.

PS. The size of the black zones in those 2 images of the spaceship may be diffrent but It's a little variation ;)

Thank you advance,
Moebius
Title: Re: Inside the spaceship & 3 Aliens
Post by: Damien on Mon 16/01/2006 22:40:07
Please, convert images to gif or png format before diplaying them here. The reason is a big difference in the image's filesize. The BG you posted has 300kb, when in png format it would probably take up around 30kb.

If you need a good host for your sprites, I suggest using Photobucket.com (http://photobucket.com).

Then you can use the following code to display them here:

[img]The link to your image[/img]

although it's not that necessary since an album with your images and BB codes for them will be generated.

Now for the crits:

Background:

First select a light source (or a few of them) and shade accordingly. You might want to ditch the black outlines by replacing them with a darker shade of a color nearest to them. You could also add some of the following to fill the space up:
-chairs
-pipes
-rivets
-panels
-wires
-use your imagination for more :)

Characters:

I suggest moving their lightsource right above them, that way you'll get mostly consistent shading on most backgrounds. The thing about black outlines applies here too.
I like how you drew their bodies, but the heads seem a bit too big. If you're going for a cartoony comical style, that's ok.

Also, you're using saturated colors, here's an image to explain what I mean:

(http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y178/DrunkyDuck/Saturation.gif)

Experiment when picking colors and draw out your palette at a side when working with sprites, that helps a lot.
Title: Re: Inside the spaceship & 3 Aliens
Post by: DonB on Mon 16/01/2006 23:17:32
I like the aliens much!  ;D
The background doesn't seem to be complete.. it seems to me its cut in 2 halfs.. and only the above half is viewable.. looks fine tho..

About the aliens; make the outsides of the aliens a darker color of the insides.. that always works better on sprites then just black outlines.. i always used black outlines as well.. but the guys here tought me darker color of the inside is way better! Try it out and be amazed!
Title: Re: Inside the spaceship & 3 Aliens
Post by: Moebius on Tue 17/01/2006 09:55:43
Hey guys, thanks for your criticism

Sorry for the links and bmps but I isn't matter that I don't know how to do it but I just havn't got much time. Now I havn't got much time too, so you'll not saw the images at forum :( (But the truth is that I was first put here images in bmp and I saw the funny picture with "I'm with stupid" txt (or something like this) )

Ow, and the host thing - I use my own server and I don't want to change him ;)

I'm still workin' on the background - and I'll thought about your sugestions.
I'm go for the holidays (at the moment :D), so I'll worry about that later.

The aliens are in cartoon style and size of their hads are intended (fi number ;) )

When I'll back than I'll put here the updated version.

Thanks,
Moebius