Adventure Game Studio

Creative Production => Critics' Lounge => Topic started by: Simonsez128 on Wed 17/01/2007 18:33:58

Title: Possible main character
Post by: Simonsez128 on Wed 17/01/2007 18:33:58
Here's Matt, a possible character for a game I'm having in mind.
How do you like him?

X2
(http://img413.imageshack.us/img413/9503/mattem1.gif)

regular size
(http://img413.imageshack.us/img413/9170/mattnp0.gif)
Title: Re: Possible main character
Post by: esper on Thu 18/01/2007 06:50:00
My first crit back from my long hiatus! Yay!

This is really, really nice. Better than I could do (all my art for my games is normally just static high-res drawings). I love pixel art and and envy people who can do it well. From an art standpoint, I think the overall angle could stand to be moved a bit counterclockwise. It looks like he's just getting ready to move into one of those Michael Jackson Moonwalk leans. Also, he's got tremendous detail, especially in the hair (which I really like), but the hands are just kind of blobby. One last thing: the hoodie looks like it's pulled against his neck and leaning off to one side. I think you should add a bit of hanging hoodie material on the left side to remedy that.

Awesome pic, man. Again, I envy your ability.
Title: Re: Possible main character
Post by: Simonsez128 on Thu 18/01/2007 08:56:33
Thanks for the crits Esper!

That was really constructive. I changed the details you mentioned.
Here's the updated version. Changed the hoody, added detail to the hands and shifted his legs a little so it doesn't seem as if he was leaning. He's supposed to be rotated slightly clockwise from a straight forward pose though.

before(http://img413.imageshack.us/img413/9503/mattem1.gif)Ã,  after(http://img267.imageshack.us/img267/4533/mattbiged1.gif)
Title: Re: Possible main character
Post by: esper on Thu 18/01/2007 10:40:53
 :D oops. I think we're using the wrong terminology here, but I meant clockwise, not counter-clockwise. It seems from the looks of the edit that you understood me though  :)

Looks good, and even the very minute details make for a huge change in the overall quality of the pic. Good work.
Title: Re: Possible main character
Post by: Boney on Thu 18/01/2007 10:48:20
it looks a little like he's trying hard to keep his arms straight down... unless he's guarding something maybe you could make them more relaxed.

nice sprite though!

EDIT:
just a quick paint over
(http://i22.photobucket.com/albums/b319/Knoglefar/po.jpg)
Title: Re: Possible main character
Post by: Simonsez128 on Thu 18/01/2007 15:35:55
Hey Boney, nice edit.
It's a good observation that his arms seem to be too straight. I really didn't mean for him to stand at "attention" :)

Alrighty then, back to work!
Title: Re: Possible main character
Post by: Joe on Wed 24/01/2007 18:31:33
Hey nice character!

But that mouth pixel made me think he was nervous

(http://joecarlhr.googlepages.com/po.PNG)

*just removeed one mouth pixel from the last edit
Title: Re: Possible main character
Post by: Buckethead on Wed 24/01/2007 18:44:22
He still looks nerveous and shy IMO. He looks to be slighly bending through his knees. He doesn't look in the camera. Looks like he's avoiding eye contact. His pose a bit weak like he's nerveous.