Adventure Game Studio

Creative Production => Critics' Lounge => Topic started by: .. on Wed 12/01/2005 19:45:13

Title: Short Poem
Post by: .. on Wed 12/01/2005 19:45:13
This is a very short poem I wrote after the tsunami disaster, basically saying that no matter what we do, nature will always be more powerfull than us, and we should realise it.

It's called Warning

We can fight back with new invention
But heed warning from the past
No matter what our intervention,
Nature laughs last

It's meant to be short and powerfull, any critique or opinions would be great
Title: Re: Short Poem
Post by: Ginny on Wed 12/01/2005 21:34:12
I like it, the last line especcially, it's powerful. Keep it up :)
Title: Re: Short Poem
Post by: on Sat 15/01/2005 03:56:10
My experience is that aspiring poets tend to have a good sense of rhymed couplets (or ABAB format), but pay much less attention to meter, consonance, assonance, and word choice.Ã,  I commend to you, e.g., Seamus Heaney's Beowulf, Shakespeare's sonnets and blank verse, and e.e. cummings.

To be more pointed:

9 beats
7 beats
9 beats
4 beats

The last line is misssing three beats to its meter.

. . . | . . . | .
. | . | . . |
. | . | . | . | .
| . | .

That's what your rhythm looks like in terms of stressed and non-stressed beats.  Do you notice how uneven it is?  Is there a reason for that -- be honest with yourself.  Divergence from natural rhythms is justifiable when it's meant to prove a point -- a missing beat can be very powerful.  But chaos is useless.

Do you really think "intervention" and "invention" are poetic words?Ã,  Anglosaxon is probably the most poetic etymology for English.Ã,  Latinate words like that are much prosier.

Are we really "fighting back"?Ã,  Note that the second line scans right now as "but [we can] heed warning from the past."Ã,  Consider inserting "must" where grammatically "we can" is being implied.

English naturally falls into iambic rhythm.Ã,  I find iambic tetrameter (i AM, i AM, i AM, i AM) to be the easiest form for starting out.

Anyway, nice start, just some things to think about.
Title: Re: Short Poem
Post by: Andail on Sat 15/01/2005 10:58:20
Not only are intervention and invention boring words to use in a short poem like this, making them rhyme is pretty awkward actually.
Title: Re: Short Poem
Post by: lo_res_man on Tue 18/01/2005 23:33:43
If i may be so bold i say, i like it, it reminds me of the beatnik poetry in grim fendango, but in a GOOD way,