Adventure Game Studio

Creative Production => Critics' Lounge => Topic started by: Neutron on Sun 17/04/2005 22:08:48

Title: The House of FogHat FineBean ( new update pg2 )
Post by: Neutron on Sun 17/04/2005 22:08:48
this is the potion makers house.Ã,  i know it's kind of dark, but it's supposed to be a bit dark.
(http://home.att.net/~yorik/foghouse1.jpg)
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean
Post by: Stefano on Sun 17/04/2005 22:48:40
I do not think is dark. I think is great!  ;)

Two things bothered me, though:
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean
Post by: Neutron on Sun 17/04/2005 22:52:55
hm, i think you're right.  i'll make a new bark texture.
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean
Post by: Neutron on Sun 17/04/2005 23:51:45
ok, i think this bark works ok,... i gave it a stronger suggestion of a lightbulb as well.  changed the levels slightly too.
(http://home.att.net/~yorik/foghouse3.jpg)
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean
Post by: Vince Twelve on Mon 18/04/2005 03:04:56
The new version looks much better, though I think the bark could still use a bit more of the vertical lines.

Also, I would give the base of the house a different color to make it contrast the background a bit more.

I would also like to see some more bushes or vegetation stretching along that back.  Anything that gives a visual indication that I can't exit to the north (unless I can... in which case it needs more visual indication that I CAN) so I won't waste my time walking around up there or run into an invisible wall.

Really looking forward to this project.  Looks amazing.
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean
Post by: Gregjazz on Mon 18/04/2005 07:04:55
Quote from: Neutron on Sun 17/04/2005 23:51:45
ok, i think this bark works ok,... i gave it a stronger suggestion of a lightbulb as well.  changed the levels slightly too.
(http://home.att.net/~yorik/foghouse3.jpg)

Time to add some roots to those trees! Also, what if you made the top of the mushroom house lopsided to give it more character? Like have it bent sideways and kinda tapered, so it's bigger on one side. Also, what if you had a little dirt path that goes to the door? Also try turning down the brightness of the light above the door -- it attracts too much attention, IMO.
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean
Post by: Neutron on Mon 18/04/2005 18:17:21
i left them smooth on purpose.  note that not all trees have defined roots at the base.  especially coniferous trees tend not to.  lots of things i could do to this pic, really, but the real beauty of this pic, is that i did it in less than a day, and i can move on to the next thing.  in this case making the character for foghat finebean.  btw, there will be exits off all sides in this screen.
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean ( updated with character )
Post by: Neutron on Mon 18/04/2005 18:47:41
here's my sketch for foghat finebean.  he will probably take a couple days to make, but with luck i'll finish him today.
(http://home.att.net/~yorik/foghatfinebean.jpg)
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean ( updated with character )
Post by: Ubel on Mon 18/04/2005 19:29:13
That's just great man! Just great! I love it. Wonderful! :D I especially like the way you've made the hat.

Totally waiting for the game!
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean ( another character update )
Post by: Neutron on Mon 18/04/2005 21:34:29
thanks.  here's another update.  i guess i will finish him today.  still i need to rig/animate him.  i think i will portray him gardening in the herb patch.
(http://home.att.net/~yorik/foggy1.png)
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean ( another character update )
Post by: on Mon 18/04/2005 21:54:26
Quote from: Neutron on Mon 18/04/2005 21:34:29
thanks.  here's another update.  i guess i will finish him today.  still i need to rig/animate him.  i think i will portray him gardening in the herb patch.
(http://home.att.net/~yorik/foggy1.png)

What program do you use to model you're characters? You seem to do them extremely well, I've tried it myself and am not good at character modelling.
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean ( character update 2 )
Post by: Neutron on Mon 18/04/2005 22:36:19
use blender or wings.  both free, both good modelling programs.  3dsMax and lightwave are good, but expensive.  z-brush is good too, but is also expensive.  it has a unique approach to making models though, which some people find more suitable, and is especially good for high poly stuff and bump mapping.
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean ( character update 2 )
Post by: Neutron on Tue 19/04/2005 01:28:53
rigged him and rendered his normal view>>
(http://home.att.net/~yorik/fog1frms.gif)
i don't think he'll need to walk yet, so i'm going to make a gardening anim
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean ( character update 2 )
Post by: Stefano on Tue 19/04/2005 01:34:37
Ha! This guy soooo fits the house. I imagined he would look like this.  ;D
Ever considered giving him a pipe?

Loved your "sketch".

Cheers,
Stefano
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean ( updated views )
Post by: stuh505 on Tue 19/04/2005 01:41:59
Your character model is very nicely done. Ã, Will the beard be a soft body?

Your scene looks not nearly as good as the character, unfortunately.

The texture on the trees is still looking very much like rock to me. Ã, I suggest you use a high amount of sub-pixel displacement, and a much more treelike and striated texture...perhaps more brownish in color.

Your tree models are also quite simple, and I think they would benefit from a few branches.

But most importantly, I think you need to add more vegetation in the forest, it looks very much like a flat infinite ground plane with some pillars coming out of it, and does not give the forest atmosphere!

Finally, please align your camera so that the horizon is horizontal.

Alias,

I can't suggest Max or ZBrush for modelling. Ã, While Max is a great program capable of modelling, it's a all purpose program and modelling in it is far more tedious than in dedicated modelling programs. Ã, ZBrush is an amazing program, and it is NOT a suitable choice for general purpose modelling...it can be good for organic modelling, but it's primary advantage is the ability to create displacement maps. Ã, Having tried Max, Maya, Blender, ZBrush, XSI, Rhino, Silo, Modo, and Wings 3D, my personal preference is Silo, which is cheapest to all but Wings which is free.  It's very much like Wings actually.
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean ( updated views )
Post by: Neutron on Tue 19/04/2005 01:55:52
you're right, the camera is slightly tilted to one side, but straightening it won't cause the horizon to become straight, since it is not a plane but a displaced grid, and is higher on the left than it is on the right.Ã,  you're right though, it needs more twigs on the ground, and possibly a couple of bare branches hanging down.Ã,  I guess i might as well sink some more time into it, since it is a scene that the character will come back to again and again.Ã, 
<edit> oh, and good call on the pipe.  i think i'll work that in later when they go in the house.
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean ( updated views )
Post by: stuh505 on Tue 19/04/2005 02:00:45
I know how daunting it is to create all that groundcover and foliage and stuff.  You might consider a few options to ease your life, such as 1) getting an app that will make generating trees and bushes etc easier, like XFrog 2) rendering your trees and foliage separately so that you can composite tons of them into one image in Photoshop without suffering through hours of rendering time.
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean ( updated views )
Post by: Neutron on Tue 19/04/2005 02:04:18
no worries, i've done highly vegetated scenes before.  the trick to not having a sluggish scene that is full of tons of vertices is to render the background in layers, and then, instead of having 50 high poly plants in your scene you have just a few in the foreground.  those sunflowers alone are packed with polys.
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean ( updated views )
Post by: Neutron on Tue 19/04/2005 04:29:08
ok i added some stuff,...how's this,...
(http://home.att.net/~yorik/newfoghouse1.jpg)
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean ( updated again )
Post by: stuh505 on Tue 19/04/2005 06:50:55
Ok, a little better...you've got 6 or 7 plants...how about 300?  It just looks so darn empty back there.  And still, that bark doesnt look anything like a tree.

heres a quick little photoshop jobby to show you slightly closer to how im imagining it...instead of pasting a bunch of individual plants i used some parts of a forest image for a faster edit

(http://www.2dadventure.com/ags/moreplants.jpg)
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean ( updated again )
Post by: Neutron on Tue 19/04/2005 07:12:29
ok, i'll fool with it a bit tommorow.  i don't want it to get too claustrophobic though.
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean ( updated again )
Post by: Neutron on Tue 19/04/2005 18:23:09
i added some brush in the background.  i think it looks better now, but i don't want to get too carried away. 
(http://home.att.net/~yorik/newfoghouse2.jpg)
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean ( new update pg2 )
Post by: on Tue 19/04/2005 21:50:07
You must be very experienced no? What about the backgrounds?
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean ( new update pg2 )
Post by: Neutron on Tue 19/04/2005 22:03:28
same deal, just more complicated.
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean ( new update pg2 )
Post by: Abisso on Wed 20/04/2005 11:04:48
Don't get angry with me, but I think that the gnomish char in the sketch is far, far better then his 3D counterpart! You should really do a 2D game, it would be cooler.
And to be more precise, you're so good at drawing that I don't see why you choose the 3D style.
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean ( new update pg2 )
Post by: danny* on Wed 20/04/2005 11:28:44
Quote from: Abisso on Wed 20/04/2005 11:04:48
the gnomish char in the sketch is far, far better then his 3D counterpart!
I agree!!
(the 3d character is great ,too,..but the 2d one is just better)
Sorry...
Title: Re: The House of FogHat FineBean ( new update pg2 )
Post by: Neutron on Wed 20/04/2005 19:32:21
I'm trying to be economical as far as the time i spend putting this together.  Since it is my first attempt at a game it will no doubt be buggy, and have a variety of other problems.  Making animation loops goes alot faster, because once you set up the character with a walk cycle, it takes about 2 minutes or less to make all 8 views of animation.  By the same token, I could spend more time on the 3D character, and actually get him to look quite like the picture, but I don't want to get too bogged down in any one thing, or this might end up on the shelf.