Adventure Game Studio

Community => General Discussion => Topic started by: auhsor on Tue 22/03/2005 09:24:57

Title: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: auhsor on Tue 22/03/2005 09:24:57
...And it's driving me crazy. I have been trying for the past half hour and still havn't figured it out.

Again it has something to do with the name, and it's not about chess.

Check it out at: http://www.thepetersengraph.com/

???
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: Kinoko on Tue 22/03/2005 11:42:21
It's driving me somewhat crazy too. I've had a couple of good theories but they haven't worked out. It's annoying, because after knowing Petals Around The Rose, you think, "Ahh, I'll be able to get THIS one quickly".
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: auhsor on Tue 22/03/2005 11:44:51
Yeah I know, It's so frustrating.  I thought I had worked it out before, but unfortunately it wasn't so.
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: SSH on Tue 22/03/2005 11:58:10
You can check out the source code of the page to find the algorithm....  ;)

or google.

Here's my hint:

IT IS NOT SIMPLE.

It is not like Petals around the rose, it is a proper math-ish algorithm, which is kind of disappointing (read: lame) really.
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: Kinoko on Tue 22/03/2005 11:59:15
I just read the comments on the page and they pretty much said it isn't a complicated maths problem

What I'm really interested in is whether its a visual solution or, as SSH said (not that I'm doubting you) a number problem

EDIT: Okay, my current theories are:

Spoiler

It's to do with the pairs of numbers
[close]

Spoiler

It's to do with the dots on opposing sides of the dice
[close]

Spoiler

It's to do with how many dots you have to add or subtract to equal something else
[close]

Spoiler

It's to do with the colour. But that's a really weak theory.
[close]
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: SpacePirateCaine on Tue 22/03/2005 12:31:36
I have no clue at all how this works, either. However, you can play around, testing theories by manually entering numbers into the fields below the dice, instead of randomly rolling. All I've figured out so far is that the order the dice are in does seem to matter.
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: SSH on Tue 22/03/2005 12:37:45
Spoiler

Number 1 is the best theory
[close]

Quote from: Kinoko on Tue 22/03/2005 11:59:15
I just read the comments on the page and they pretty much said it isn't a complicated maths problem

What I'm really interested in is whether its a visual solution or, as SSH said (not that I'm doubting you) a number problem

EDIT: Okay, my current theories are:

Spoiler

It's to do with the pairs of numbers
[close]

Spoiler

It's to do with the dots on opposing sides of the dice
[close]

Spoiler

It's to do with how many dots you have to add or subtract to equal something else
[close]

Spoiler

It's to do with the colour. But that's a really weak theory.
[close]

Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: Kinoko on Tue 22/03/2005 12:42:14
Okay, I've figured the 6th dice out, and I have noticed a pattern, but... still no answer
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: SSH on Tue 22/03/2005 12:45:17
6th dice? There are only 5!

Another hint:
Spoiler

Maybe Zapmate would be a better name for the game
[close]
and
Spoiler

the whole thing would be easier, more logical and less lame if all the answers were 3 bigger
[close]
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: Kinoko on Tue 22/03/2005 12:47:08
I am SO close to getting this, I have a theory that works 80% of the time...

EDIT: Oh, whoops! I meant 5th

EDIT: Okay, getting closer, I -think-...

Spoiler

The 5th dice seems to indicate the right number when it's on 3, but will add 1 if it's 4, 2 if it's 5, etc...
The other four... At first, I thought it was the number of a certain dice (if not one) added to it's value... but that doesn't work all the time.
Then I thought, you take out any pairs of dice, and then add the non-pairs together... but that doesn't work all the time.
[close]
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: SSH on Tue 22/03/2005 12:59:21
Sounds like you're getting further away.

Have you ever played Stratego?
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: Kinoko on Tue 22/03/2005 12:59:48
Damnit! ^_^ No...

EDIT:
Spoiler

I've noticed the 2nd and 4th dices values' work differently to the 1st and 3rd... am I imagining it?
[close]
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: SSH on Tue 22/03/2005 13:24:50
That's an important observation, but it kind of happens by accident... think Darwinism

Spoiler

The world is a tough place. Some will take advantage of anyone near them who is smaller than they are and crush them completely.
[close]
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: Kinoko on Tue 22/03/2005 13:45:00
Okay, I have it now, and it's retarded. I hate being one of those people that bitches about puzzles they found hard, but... this had bugger all to do with the title. NOTHING! It wasn't like Petals Around the Rose at ALL, it was a completely different concept.

*sigh* I'm just sorry I wasted part of my life on this thing.
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: SSH on Tue 22/03/2005 13:56:08
Told you so
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: Kinoko on Tue 22/03/2005 13:59:54
I'm SO sorry I didn't listen -_- I hope you can forgive me.

I encourage noone to attempt this. It's senseless and lame, and not clever in the slightest.
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: Haddas on Tue 22/03/2005 15:19:00
Then, could you tell me how it works? I don't want to solve it, I just want to know why it's lame.
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: SSH on Tue 22/03/2005 15:41:07
Warning: full solution:
Spoiler

Start with the leftmost dice

Look at the dice to the left (if there is one) : if it is less than or the same as this dice, make that dice = 0
Look at the dice to the right (if there is one) : if it is less than or the same as this dice, make that dice = 0

Now move on to the next (non-zero) dice

So for 1 1 1 1 1:

1 1 1 1 1
1 0 1 1 1
1 0 1 0 1

Now, add up all the dice 1 + 1 + 1 = 3
Now, subtract 3   3-3 = 0

So 1 1 1 1 1 = 0

For 2 2 2 2 2:

2 2 2 2 2
2 0 2 2 2
2 0 2 0 2 summed = 6 -3 = 3

1 2 3 4 5
0 2 3 4 5
0 0 3 4 5
0 0 0 4 5
0 0 0 0 5 summed 5 -3 = 2

[close]
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: InCreator on Tue 22/03/2005 16:12:05
Hey, great game.
Great is especially the fact that I have absolutely no clue what's the game is about. Checkmate? where? What is a checkmate? What do I have to guess? I know chess, but dice...  :P

So it's like 2 puzzles to me.

...or - a great alchometer: If I get what's that dice thing is about, i'm definetly drunk! :D
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: voh on Wed 23/03/2005 15:05:31
Like mentioned, the name is important. Don't think of it as a chess-related term, but more of what the name would indicate :)

BTW, I solved it on my own. Took me about an hour :P
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: Kairus on Sat 26/03/2005 02:30:39
Ok after some time I could finally solve how the "petals around the rose" worked. Yes, it sounds lame, but I couldn't do it the first time I played it. Now I think I have it, except for the fact that I didn't at all think of the relation to the petals around a rose. I just thought about it in a mathematical way.
Can anyone explain me how the solution is related to the petals around a rose??

Spoiler

My solution to the game was: (sum of the odd dices) - (amount of odd dices)
[close]
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: voh on Sat 26/03/2005 13:47:12
Spoiler

It is the solution, but can you explain why it is? You know, in relation to the name and all?
[close]

:)
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: Kairus on Sat 26/03/2005 15:57:15
No, really, I can't tell how it relates to a rose and its petals. :(
Can you tell me?
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: Al_Ninio on Sat 26/03/2005 18:18:55
It doesn't relate to a rose and its petals...
It just shares a similiarity to a game called "Petals Around the Rose". :P
Which can be found here: http://www.borrett.id.au/computing/petals-j.htm
Or the AGS version, courtesy of Hotspot: http://maddtrix.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/petalrose.zip
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: voh on Sat 26/03/2005 18:23:45
Quote from: Al_Ninio on Sat 26/03/2005 18:18:55
It doesn't relate to a rose and its petals...
It just shares a similiarity to a game called "Petals Around the Rose". :P
Which can be found here: http://www.borrett.id.au/computing/petals-j.htm

As far as I've noticed, kairus was actually talking about Petals around the Rose :)
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: Al_Ninio on Sat 26/03/2005 18:50:32
Ah, sorry, then.
In that case:
Spoiler
All odd dice have a dot in the middle. That is the rose. The dots around the middle one are the petals. Simply count them, and you have succeeded!
[close]

Sorry if I misunderstood, anyway. :P
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: Kairus on Sat 26/03/2005 23:56:46
Oh, thank you Al Ninio, that explains everything. I'm sure I'd never have thought of it.
Title: Re: Checkmate!: Another "Petals Around The Rose" type game
Post by: Afflict on Sun 27/03/2005 18:53:16
The fields under the dices can be altered to what you want them... Nice little tip. :)
now you can ffigure it out. BTW ssh

1 2 3 4 5 = 6

Try again...