Adventure Game Studio

Community => General Discussion => Topic started by: Dualnames on Wed 02/09/2009 07:58:21

Title: Ye Old Compression Topic( Musicians that HAVE worked with AGS may be interested)
Post by: Dualnames on Wed 02/09/2009 07:58:21
I'm composing the music on a game, and I'm wondering you guys that have composed music before how do you send your music files? Do you compress them into a certain format(mp3, ogg) and send them? Do you allow authors to compress them as they like? What's really the best thing to do in order not to have a ginormous music vox file but still maintain music quality?
Title: Re: Ye Old Compression Topic( Musicians that HAVE worked with AGS may be interested)
Post by: Phemar on Wed 02/09/2009 09:53:50
Generally you would compress all you music, except the original recordings. The final product should definitely be compressed. Ogg or mp3 should be fine, although mp3 does have licensing issues.
Title: Re: Ye Old Compression Topic( Musicians that HAVE worked with AGS may be interested)
Post by: Intense Degree on Wed 02/09/2009 09:56:04
Personally I would always go for .ogg unless you are recording live music or something where the quality was paramount. At the end of the day it will be compressed down for a game and if it is synthesized music (i.e. not real recorded instruments) you won't lose much with ogg.

EDIT: Looks like Phemar beat me to it!
Title: Re: Ye Old Compression Topic( Musicians that HAVE worked with AGS may be interested)
Post by: Dualnames on Wed 02/09/2009 10:51:33
oCompressed to what bitrate though? Or just keep the 1440 bitrate from the wav and just compress it to a 1440 bitrate ogg/mp3?
Title: Re: Ye Old Compression Topic( Musicians that HAVE worked with AGS may be interested)
Post by: Phemar on Wed 02/09/2009 10:52:57
128 should be more than enough. :D
Title: Re: Ye Old Compression Topic( Musicians that HAVE worked with AGS may be interested)
Post by: Ishmael on Wed 02/09/2009 12:01:20
Depending on instruments 128 messes some frequencies up. 160 is the more than enough option for MP3, Ogg quality 5 is about the same but compresses better IIRC. Might be wrong though, been a while since I concidered myself with size of files when compressing :P
Title: Re: Ye Old Compression Topic( Musicians that HAVE worked with AGS may be interested)
Post by: Phemar on Wed 02/09/2009 14:13:52
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_audio_codecs

Handy page if you're still unsure.