New "Black Stories" Crime Riddles

[JackPutter]

Did Harland get caught on purpose?

[Cassiebsg]

Is the dungeon a police jail?
Was he forced into the dungeon?
Did he walk into the dungeon by himself?
Was he locked in on purpose?
Was he committing a crime  when he was locked in the dungeon?

[Stupot]

Did Harland accidentally lock himself in the dungeon?
Did Harland deliberately lock himself in the dungeon?
Was he covering for the person who actually committed the crime?

[heltenjon]

Is the dungeon real? (Not metaphorical or virtual/computerized.)
Did he like being in the dungeon?

[Mandle]

Case #64

Harland was a good man who was locked in a dungeon for a crime he didn't commit but got what he deserved.

YES
Is Harland still alive?
Is Harland human?
Is the dungeon a police jail?
Was he forced into the dungeon?
Was he locked in on purpose?
Is the dungeon real? (Not metaphorical or virtual/computerized.)



NO
Was Harland a masochist?
Did Harland commit a different crime than the one he got locked up for?
Did Harland get caught on purpose?
Did he walk into the dungeon by himself? (Not of his own free will)
Was he committing a crime  when he was locked in the dungeon?
Did Harland accidentally lock himself in the dungeon?
Did Harland deliberately lock himself in the dungeon?
Was he covering for the person who actually committed the crime?
Did he like being in the dungeon?


IRRELEVANT / IMPOSSIBLE TO KNOW

[JackPutter]

Is Harland still in the dungeon?
Was he released from the dungeon?
Was he compensated for his wrongful imprisonment?

[Ian Aloser]

Was Harland taken for somebody else ?
Does Harland have a lookalike?

[Mandle]

Case #64

Harland was a good man who was locked in a dungeon for a crime he didn't commit but got what he deserved.

YES
Is Harland still alive?
Is Harland human?
Is the dungeon a police jail?
Was he forced into the dungeon?
Was he locked in on purpose?
Is the dungeon real? (Not metaphorical or virtual/computerized.)
Was he released from the dungeon?
Was he compensated for his wrongful imprisonment? (Kind of)



NO
Was Harland a masochist?
Did Harland commit a different crime than the one he got locked up for?
Did Harland get caught on purpose?
Did he walk into the dungeon by himself? (Not of his own free will)
Was he committing a crime  when he was locked in the dungeon?
Did Harland accidentally lock himself in the dungeon?
Did Harland deliberately lock himself in the dungeon?
Was he covering for the person who actually committed the crime?
Did he like being in the dungeon?
Is Harland still in the dungeon?
Was Harland taken for somebody else ?
Does Harland have a lookalike?


IRRELEVANT / IMPOSSIBLE TO KNOW

[JackPutter]

Was Harland sick?
Did he receive treatment for an illness while in captivity?
Did he receive treatment for an illness after he was released?
Did Harland provide a false confession?

[Mandle]

Case #64

Harland was a good man who was locked in a dungeon for a crime he didn't commit but got what he deserved.

YES
Is Harland still alive?
Is Harland human?
Is the dungeon a police jail?
Was he forced into the dungeon?
Was he locked in on purpose?
Is the dungeon real? (Not metaphorical or virtual/computerized.)
Was he released from the dungeon?
Was he compensated for his wrongful imprisonment? (Kind of)
Did he receive treatment for an illness after he was released?



NO
Was Harland a masochist?
Did Harland commit a different crime than the one he got locked up for?
Did Harland get caught on purpose?
Did he walk into the dungeon by himself? (Not of his own free will)
Was he committing a crime  when he was locked in the dungeon?
Did Harland accidentally lock himself in the dungeon?
Did Harland deliberately lock himself in the dungeon?
Was he covering for the person who actually committed the crime?
Did he like being in the dungeon?
Is Harland still in the dungeon?
Was Harland taken for somebody else ?
Does Harland have a lookalike?
Was Harland sick?
Did he receive treatment for an illness while in captivity?
Did Harland provide a false confession?


IRRELEVANT / IMPOSSIBLE TO KNOW

[Ian Aloser]

Is Harland's profession of importance for the solution ?
Is Harland the forename?
Is Harland the surname?

[heltenjon]

Was Harland locked up to preserve evidence?
Had he eaten or ingested something of importance for the case?
Was the real criminal also arrested?

[Stupot]

Was the real perpetrator known to Harland?
Was the real perpetrator related to Harland?
Was Harland tricked?
Did he get “what he deserved” because he had committed a separate criminal act?
Did he get “what he deserved” because he had done something stupid, rather than criminal?

[Snarky]

Did he "get what he deserved" because he benefited from being in jail?
Was Harland a victim of the crime?
Did the person who actually committed the crime get caught?
Did Harland help find the actual criminal?

[Riaise]

Was Harland found at the scene of the crime?
Did Harland know that a crime had been committed?
Was Harland drunk?

[Mandle]

Case #64

Harland was a good man who was locked in a dungeon for a crime he didn't commit but got what he deserved.

YES
Is Harland still alive?
Is Harland human?
Is the dungeon a police jail?
Was he forced into the dungeon?
Was he locked in on purpose?
Is the dungeon real? (Not metaphorical or virtual/computerized.)
Was he released from the dungeon?
Was he compensated for his wrongful imprisonment? (Kind of)
Did he receive treatment for an illness after he was released?
Is Harland the forename?
Did he "get what he deserved" because he benefited from being in jail?
Was Harland a victim of a crime? (Technically, yes)



NO
Was Harland a masochist?
Did Harland commit a different crime than the one he got locked up for?
Did Harland get caught on purpose?
Did he walk into the dungeon by himself? (Not of his own free will)
Was he committing a crime  when he was locked in the dungeon?
Did Harland accidentally lock himself in the dungeon?
Did Harland deliberately lock himself in the dungeon?
Was he covering for the person who actually committed the crime?
Did he like being in the dungeon?
Is Harland still in the dungeon?
Was Harland taken for somebody else ?
Does Harland have a lookalike?
Was Harland sick?
Did he receive treatment for an illness while in captivity?
Did Harland provide a false confession?
Is Harland's profession of importance for the solution ?
Is Harland the surname?
Was Harland locked up to preserve evidence?
Had he eaten or ingested something of importance for the case?
Was the real criminal also arrested?
Was the real perpetrator known to Harland?
Was the real perpetrator related to Harland?
Was Harland tricked?
Did he get “what he deserved” because he had committed a separate criminal act?
Did he get “what he deserved” because he had done something stupid, rather than criminal?
Did the person who actually committed the crime get caught?
Did Harland help find the actual criminal?
Was Harland found at the scene of the crime?
Did Harland know that a crime had been committed?
Was Harland drunk?


IRRELEVANT / IMPOSSIBLE TO KNOW

[Ian Aloser]

Is the committed crime a murder?
Is the committed crime a burglary?
Did Harland get injured in the dungeon?
Was he compensated for his wrongful imprisonment in terms of money?
Was there a crime committed at all?

[Stupot]

Was he put in the dungeon for his own protection?
Was he put in the dungeon to protect others?
Was he the same form going into the dungeon as he was coming out?
Was he a werewolf?

[Mandle]

Case #64

Harland was a good man who was locked in a dungeon for a crime he didn't commit but got what he deserved.

YES
Is Harland still alive?
Is Harland human?
Is the dungeon a police jail?
Was he forced into the dungeon?
Was he locked in on purpose?
Is the dungeon real? (Not metaphorical or virtual/computerized.)
Was he released from the dungeon?
Was he compensated for his wrongful imprisonment? (Kind of)
Did he receive treatment for an illness after he was released?
Is Harland the forename?
Did he "get what he deserved" because he benefited from being in jail?
Was Harland a victim of a crime? (Technically, yes)
Did Harland get injured in the dungeon?
Was he the same form going into the dungeon as he was coming out?
Was he put in the dungeon to protect others?



NO
Was Harland a masochist?
Did Harland commit a different crime than the one he got locked up for?
Did Harland get caught on purpose?
Did he walk into the dungeon by himself? (Not of his own free will)
Was he committing a crime  when he was locked in the dungeon?
Did Harland accidentally lock himself in the dungeon?
Did Harland deliberately lock himself in the dungeon?
Was he covering for the person who actually committed the crime?
Did he like being in the dungeon?
Is Harland still in the dungeon?
Was Harland taken for somebody else ?
Does Harland have a lookalike?
Was Harland sick?
Did he receive treatment for an illness while in captivity?
Did Harland provide a false confession?
Is Harland's profession of importance for the solution ?
Is Harland the surname?
Was Harland locked up to preserve evidence?
Had he eaten or ingested something of importance for the case?
Was the real criminal also arrested?
Was the real perpetrator known to Harland?
Was the real perpetrator related to Harland?
Was Harland tricked?
Did he get “what he deserved” because he had committed a separate criminal act?
Did he get “what he deserved” because he had done something stupid, rather than criminal?
Did the person who actually committed the crime get caught?
Did Harland help find the actual criminal?
Was Harland found at the scene of the crime?
Did Harland know that a crime had been committed?
Was Harland drunk?
Is the committed crime a murder?
Is the committed crime a burglary?
Was he compensated for his wrongful imprisonment in terms of money?
Was there a crime committed at all?
Was he put in the dungeon for his own protection?
Was he a werewolf?


IRRELEVANT / IMPOSSIBLE TO KNOW

[Mandle]

I will mention here that I missed a nuance of language in responding to a question before:

The original question was:

YES
Was Harland a victim of the crime? (Technically, yes)


Which has been adjusted to:

YES
Was Harland a victim of a crime? (Technically, yes)