Just finished the game! It's really a great game, I enjoyed the heck out of it. Here's a few of my thoughts:
1. I didn't get the Geoff/church bug, so I'm wondering if I either wasn't paying attention, or if it's even occurring across the board for everyone.
2. I'm happy to know that you'll be adding the save/load (etc.) instructions to the game as well. I knew how to trigger them, but only because I happened to read the "readme", and like you said, many people don't usually do that. The walk speed increase button (+) is much appreciated too because without it, I felt like the character moves across the screen way too slowly. (Not a big deal at all, just something I noticed.)
3. The gameplay was a lot of fun for me. I liked the narrator's sense of humor, and although there's not a unique response for EVERYTHING you try to do in the game (which I'm sure would take forever to write and code), there are some pretty funny lines that cracked me up. The sense of humor and comedic timing in this game in general was really good, imo. Even Geoff eventually had some pretty good one-liners and grew on me. He was obviously meant to conjure up Keith vibes from Police Quest, which was fun as well.
4. The graphics (as in the first chapter) are really nice...a little pixel-hunting but not too bad. Nothing obscure or that the player can't handle anyway. The puzzles were fair I think--I had to get a few hints but I seem to ALWAYS need hints, so if I can get through a game without needing a complete walkthrough, that's a win for me.

I feel like I might know where Chapter 3 is headed...and I'm really excited to see what happens once it's released! Congrats on a great game and thank you for making it!