Quote from: RocketGirl on Sun 15/01/2006 17:38:21
Titles are annouced before they are released. It happens with movies, too. Every time Disney announces a new title, every fly-by-night animation studio out there tries to cash in by releasing their own version of, say, Aladdin, direct-to-video before Disney's hits the theater. And it happens with video games as well. I've worked at three game companies over the years and I know what development meetings are like; titles and features that other companies have announced are often part of the insipiration discussions.
So basically, whoever announce their title first are original? Conceptwise, both DAH and STZ give you a protagonist which more or less wipes out entire cityblocks of puny earthlings/walking dinners. If the similarities also would be that the opponent is placed within military bases, well it is not exactly the first time that has happened. Did DAH ripoff Area 51? Or is it the cheeky humour that makes STZ a veritable copy of DAH? Heck, both games are ripoffs of Postal since that also clearly features a protagonist whacking people into smitherins. And on more than one occasion are these people accompanied by military resources.
An announcement incorporates not much more than a concept. This is the game, you will play this and that. Gameplay features, level design, obstacle design, technical specifications, storyline etc etc is not part of an announcement, they're trying to sell you a game that does not exist yet, and even if gameplay seem alike in the final products, there is no way in hell anyone could rip off what they do not know about.
It's the postmodern world at its best. Everything has been done and will be redone again. Films, movies, whatever. I know that people want to cash in at other big titles; but a game development usually tries to stand out in one way or another, even though concepts may be very much alike. I can't honestly see how STZ would be a ripoff of DAH merely because the concepts and/or gameplay are similar, since the production time were more or less simultaneously.
Giana Sisters, now THAT is a ripoff, since it merely exchanged the protagonist, but kept gameplay, leveldesign, palettes, general feel etc etc..