Thanks for all of your recommendations! Since I've posted last, I've played through the excellent Nelly Cootalot. The charming, homespun art direction, deep feminism of the lead character (which is rare, especially WITH female characters!) and the breezy story helped to make this a definite winner. My only complaint would be is that the puzzles were a little too easy... but it was fun and satisfying to ease myself back into this at this pace, it's certainly a confidence builder running through an adventure in an evening without a walkthrough. 
I also gave Ben There, Dan That a shot, but found the puzzles rather simple, and didn't find it as funny as many others did. That's been put on hold for Chalie Foxtrot, which is very charming and hits the LucasArts-style humor spot on. I gave Apprentice Deluxe a couple of hours and was shocked at the level of professionalism and teriffic characters. I nearly died laughing at the dialogue with the dragon - great stuff.
If you happen to think of any others, let me know! Thanks again.

I also gave Ben There, Dan That a shot, but found the puzzles rather simple, and didn't find it as funny as many others did. That's been put on hold for Chalie Foxtrot, which is very charming and hits the LucasArts-style humor spot on. I gave Apprentice Deluxe a couple of hours and was shocked at the level of professionalism and teriffic characters. I nearly died laughing at the dialogue with the dragon - great stuff.
If you happen to think of any others, let me know! Thanks again.