Quote from: RickJ on Thu 01/09/2011 20:04:49QuoteIncreator didn't say that murder was natural which is what you are implying. I'll bet you did eat yesterday and everyday before that and so directly caused countless organisms to be killed so that you could consume them.
I never spend money for weapons, nor did I ever kill anybody. So either I'm violating my nature and should recieve a treatment or nature doesn't play a fucking role in people's thoughts.
So your point is that Increator made a very banal statement that is worth ignoring? Alright then.
QuoteQuoteI think it's just plain wrong; people are motivated by their emotions and their desire to maintain and improve their well being. [...] The only affect one's culture and societal structure may have is to color one's perception of "well being".
I don't think it's reductive and simplistic to explain human behavior as motivated by the structure of the society they live in...
And how can you try to achieve "well being"? You have to play by the rules, respectively transgress them if they force you into a miserable life. So all your thoughts and with them your emotions have to deal with and - in this way - become results of the structure of the society you live in.
QuoteYou're joking, right?
Here is a link to what appears to be part of a psychology text book that explains this and backs it up with studies and actual data rather than just espousing psychobabble.
QuoteThose unhallowed creatures! Didn't they learn that this is sin against God Almighty?
The recent riots can be understood in these terms. The participants were motivated by the opportunity to enhance their "well being" by
1. Experiencing pleasure
2. Acquiring material goods
Seriously, I think those are the most reasonable motivations there are.
Quote
and because of the lack of fear of the consequences. The lack of fear is due to the relatively mild punishment for such behavior and low likelyhood of any one individual being held accountable ("they can't arrest us all" mindset).
This is some very funny logic: Someone did something because he wasn't restrained from doing so!
Quote
Although the ultimate punishment is not appropriate it is sensible to discuss the appropriate consequences of rioting, looting, etc ought to be. It is also foolish and naive to believe that fear of consequences and their severity do not motivate or disincentivize people.
For all of you law-and-order fans in here: A society like this, i.e. a capitalistic, competition-based one, will always produce losers. You may want to beat them, you may want to shoot them, they will always be there and some of them will always try to get what they want in a way the state doesn't permit.
PS From my side the discussion with WHAM is over.