Who's making excuses?
I assumed I had until the end of the 18th....
An Alliance by WHAM
I thought this was an awesome story. The atmosphere was moody, the characters strong, and the background world pregnant with possibility. I agree with some of the comments already posted that it might not necessarily make for the best short story, but I think the world, characters, and plot problems all have terrific potential. I especially liked the clanish-ness of the rodent tribes and their distinct characters. My favourite character was the one-eyed mouse of the woods, just because his body tells quite the backstory and he's obviously got quite a complex set of motivations. Obviously this wasn't something explored in depth in the story, but I want to find out more about him, whereas other characters were more easy to figure out off the bat (e.g. the quick-tempered Red Tooth, the cerebral Old White...). I also liked your use of language in describing the setting as "wreathed" in fog as moonlight "crept" down the stairs. Nice strong verbs there.
A fox knows many things... by jahnocli
I very much liked the atmosphere at the beginning of the story. It had this grim foreboding feeling, which unfortunately didn't quite pan out in the end. My favourite character was Prickly, mostly for his "Dickensian" manner of speaking (who uses the term "mutual advantage" anymore?). I thought their plan was sound and the story-world plausible, except for the incongruous internet gambling bit. While painting a vivid picture in my mind, some of your descriptions also jarred a bit with the rural setting: "the fog teased like dry ice" speaks of a degree of scientific familiarity that doesn't quite seem to fit in with animals living in a forest.
Ice-cream by Sinitrena
While you've adhered to the rules, I think your entry bends the spirit of them a bit too far. Yes, we know there's something different about Kessy even before she goes all Elsa-ice-queen on the creepy fae guy. But outside of her weird look and powers, there's nothing really inhuman about her. In fact, she seems to relate more to being human than to her "real" people, right down to the shallow teenage sassy-ness of her attitude. I was intrigued by the ending about the longer backstory of her adopted family and the fairies, but shocked at her cavalier attitude in not even enquiring after her lost sister, so self-assured she was that the fairies would try to make contact again shortly (after 15 years of nothing....). Kessy is for sure the best character in your piece, because you've definitely nailed down the frustratingly impulsive attitude of the human teenage girl, but I'm sorry to say that I can't actually like her.
Votes:
Most Convincing Protagonist: Prickly, by jahnocli
Best Story: WHAM
Best Writing: WHAM

An Alliance by WHAM
I thought this was an awesome story. The atmosphere was moody, the characters strong, and the background world pregnant with possibility. I agree with some of the comments already posted that it might not necessarily make for the best short story, but I think the world, characters, and plot problems all have terrific potential. I especially liked the clanish-ness of the rodent tribes and their distinct characters. My favourite character was the one-eyed mouse of the woods, just because his body tells quite the backstory and he's obviously got quite a complex set of motivations. Obviously this wasn't something explored in depth in the story, but I want to find out more about him, whereas other characters were more easy to figure out off the bat (e.g. the quick-tempered Red Tooth, the cerebral Old White...). I also liked your use of language in describing the setting as "wreathed" in fog as moonlight "crept" down the stairs. Nice strong verbs there.
A fox knows many things... by jahnocli
I very much liked the atmosphere at the beginning of the story. It had this grim foreboding feeling, which unfortunately didn't quite pan out in the end. My favourite character was Prickly, mostly for his "Dickensian" manner of speaking (who uses the term "mutual advantage" anymore?). I thought their plan was sound and the story-world plausible, except for the incongruous internet gambling bit. While painting a vivid picture in my mind, some of your descriptions also jarred a bit with the rural setting: "the fog teased like dry ice" speaks of a degree of scientific familiarity that doesn't quite seem to fit in with animals living in a forest.
Ice-cream by Sinitrena
While you've adhered to the rules, I think your entry bends the spirit of them a bit too far. Yes, we know there's something different about Kessy even before she goes all Elsa-ice-queen on the creepy fae guy. But outside of her weird look and powers, there's nothing really inhuman about her. In fact, she seems to relate more to being human than to her "real" people, right down to the shallow teenage sassy-ness of her attitude. I was intrigued by the ending about the longer backstory of her adopted family and the fairies, but shocked at her cavalier attitude in not even enquiring after her lost sister, so self-assured she was that the fairies would try to make contact again shortly (after 15 years of nothing....). Kessy is for sure the best character in your piece, because you've definitely nailed down the frustratingly impulsive attitude of the human teenage girl, but I'm sorry to say that I can't actually like her.
Votes:
Most Convincing Protagonist: Prickly, by jahnocli
Best Story: WHAM
Best Writing: WHAM