I'd just suggest that RPG's haven't STAYED popular on the market. They've pretty much only recently come back. There was a period where the Eye of the Beholder games represented the streangth of the RPG in the market, then there were YEARS when RPG's just dissappeared from the shelves, as no one was buying them. So perhaps it's just a case of being patient for Adventure Games to come back around?
ALSO RPG's can't be the way forward for adventure games, as RPG's were around before Adventure games (as we know them) came into being. RPG's were around before COMPUTERS as we know them came into being, so turning adventure games into RPG's would be a step back, away from a format that has presumably evolved so that a very specific story can be told in a specific way. Monkey Island 3 wouldn't have worked as an RPG, nor would Day Of The Tenticle. To move FORWARD the Adventure Game would have to think of different and better ways of telling an interactive story. They'd also have to start being more origional with what stories they told. No more "save the princess" bumph...
I'm not saying that turning to the RPG is going to produce BAD games, but I think it's important to remember that it wouldn't be a step FORWARD, and wouldn't it be nicer if people moved forwards, as that IS the only way for something origional to get made?
ALSO RPG's can't be the way forward for adventure games, as RPG's were around before Adventure games (as we know them) came into being. RPG's were around before COMPUTERS as we know them came into being, so turning adventure games into RPG's would be a step back, away from a format that has presumably evolved so that a very specific story can be told in a specific way. Monkey Island 3 wouldn't have worked as an RPG, nor would Day Of The Tenticle. To move FORWARD the Adventure Game would have to think of different and better ways of telling an interactive story. They'd also have to start being more origional with what stories they told. No more "save the princess" bumph...
I'm not saying that turning to the RPG is going to produce BAD games, but I think it's important to remember that it wouldn't be a step FORWARD, and wouldn't it be nicer if people moved forwards, as that IS the only way for something origional to get made?
