My condolences about David. And I naturally feel somewhat bad for crapping all over a touching and obviously personal story, but it must be said (again):
Even without bringing in the circumstances involving the cat (broken routine, etc) consider hindsight bias, outcome bias, confirmation bias... The cognitive mechanisms that make us perceive "phenomena" like these are strong and well-established enough that something way more awesome ought to happen before fantastic explanations are desirable. I read about the nursing home death-predicting cat (not the original story, however), and it didn't seem impressive to me. Add all the biases inherent in journalism, and such a story is even less convincing. Precognition and stuff would be awesome, sure...but your own brain already undoubtedly is awesome. It does a lot of things to your perception of reality that you never notice.
I can't say I'm particularly on the fence on this one right now. I am deeply enough in awe of the lump of cells in our heads that we've hardly begun to understand the inner workings of.
Even without bringing in the circumstances involving the cat (broken routine, etc) consider hindsight bias, outcome bias, confirmation bias... The cognitive mechanisms that make us perceive "phenomena" like these are strong and well-established enough that something way more awesome ought to happen before fantastic explanations are desirable. I read about the nursing home death-predicting cat (not the original story, however), and it didn't seem impressive to me. Add all the biases inherent in journalism, and such a story is even less convincing. Precognition and stuff would be awesome, sure...but your own brain already undoubtedly is awesome. It does a lot of things to your perception of reality that you never notice.
I can't say I'm particularly on the fence on this one right now. I am deeply enough in awe of the lump of cells in our heads that we've hardly begun to understand the inner workings of.