QuoteYour main character looks more cartoony, while the other character and the background look more realistic.
This is true and intentional. In the game, other characters are either realistic or something in-between, much depending how humorous is the character and his role. Since Henri is the main character in all happenings, cartoony look makes him and his character somewhat easier to recognize. I think that style balance between various characters isn't that bad if they all are compared together... there's about half of character cast used in game on image below...

QuoteI love the background, but I guess I'll never understand why people scale down an image when already utilizing a low resolution. Not that there's anything wrong with low resolutions, but why the black bars left and right?
More screen area = more work!

Actually, I try to keep all backgrounds so I won't be needing character scaling much. And compared to character, every room must be hall-sized-large then! So it's choice of either realism or eye candy. Otherwise, the effect where character is about the size of the house when outside, and enters weirdly huge room inside! - happens, as it's with many old commercial games. I don't like it much.