Quote from: DGMacphee on Wed 02/03/2005 07:01:31
Here's what you're basically saying: The Oscars should vote for just American films.
No, no. I've said if case A, then A. If case B, then B.
This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.
Show posts MenuQuote from: DGMacphee on Wed 02/03/2005 07:01:31
Here's what you're basically saying: The Oscars should vote for just American films.
Quote from: DGMacphee on Wed 02/03/2005 05:58:30Quote from: Kinoko on Wed 02/03/2005 05:32:52
Okay, they're foreign actors but they're nominated for the American films they were in, no? That was my point.
No, you're wrong. Three of them were in films not American made: Vera Drake (Staunton), Maria Full of Grace (Moreno), and Hotel Rwanda (Okonedo). And you could go one further and say Annette Being's nomination was for a British film (Being Julia), even though she's American.
QuoteQuoteI'd like to see the Oscars become more global, but it's one or the other for me, not this wishy-washy in-between state.
But it's not wishy-washy. It is global. It's an American institution, but nowhere does it say that it has to be strictly for American films. Doing so is stupid. It's like relegating the Nobel Prizes to Norwegians. Sure, Norwegians are a fine bunch, but there are geniuses and peacemakers in other countries too.
Quote
As eric asks above, does it matter what the Oscars do? In this discussion, yes, but here's the thing: The Oscars is comprised of Academy members who's purpose is to decide what films they liked. Now, I ask you this: Why should we tell them "Hey guys, you can tell the world what films you liked, but only if they're American films!" That's nonsense! People in the Academy can like films, and songs from films, from other countries. It's just like me liking films from Australia as well as America, Britian, Japan, India, Europe, etc. If you say, "Hey, they should only vote for American films." Then you might as well just relegate Americans to watching American films, Australians to Australian films, Britians to British films, etc, etc, which is equally as much nonsense. I like seeing films from other countries as much as my own.
QuoteThe Oscar are just a group of people who tell us what movies, local or foreign, they liked. And I don't think anyone here can say what movies they, or anyone else, are allowed to watch. That's the real narrow-mindedness.
function DeleteItem () {
if (currentitem>0) {
currentitem--;
}
}
if (currentitem==ltunic) ltunic--;
else if (currentitem==gchilli) gchilli--;
else if (currentitem==rchilli) rchilli--;
... etc
By continuing to use this site you agree to the use of cookies. Please visit this page to see exactly how we use these.
Page created in 0.427 seconds with 15 queries.