Perhaps it could be implimented like chapter stops in a DVD, using save games.
This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.
Show posts MenuQuote from: SSH on Tue 28/09/2004 16:40:02Quote from: Kinoko on Tue 28/09/2004 16:12:44What if a murdered killed someone out of revenge for them having hurt their child and got away with it (e.g. A Time To Kill movie).. would they then not be allowed to have kids? And what if a conviction was overturned? Medical technology can't guarantee that sterilisations are reversible, and they aren't 100% reliable, either. And that's before we even get into the whole punishment versus reform argument.
Agreed in some circumstances, but there ARE circumstances where a persons previous behavious in other areas indicates they definitely would not make good parents, or at least are at great risk of not being a good parents. I totally agree with rapists/murderers/child abusers never being allowed to have children. Not matter how reformed, the risk is too great and when you've done something as bad as that, you lose your rights in this regard for life.
QuoteBut since its impossible to measure and oh so very subjective, should it become law anywhere? I argree that there's some pretty irresponsible people around, but you just can't legislate for this kind of thing. And the whole idea stinks of the slippery slope to Eugenics.
There are some people you can just speak to and know that aren't ready for parenting. They just give off "stupidity" and "irresponsibility", and you -know-. It's a vibe... hard to measure, but in this case it's not that people should be made sterile. Just that I don't think they should have kids until they've grown up and become better people.
Quote
Quote from: SSH on Tue 28/09/2004 15:30:45Quote from: Kinoko on Tue 28/09/2004 15:17:11
I'm not talking about a parent who accidentally lets their kid scrape a knee, or a parent who has a shoplifting record from the age of 15, or a mother who can't say who the father is. We ALL know there ARE parents out there who just should not have ever gotten pregnant and don't under any circumstances deserve the right to raise a child. Children aren't toys, we all know that. A parent's responsibility is to raise another human being as well as that child needs to be raised. I can't say "To the best of their ability" because some parents' best isn't near good enough.
I'd LOVE the right to take people's children away from them when I saw them being raised by what I consider to be bad parents. However, what we want to do or what we feel people deserve isn't the goal, it's a world where ALL children are raised well, lead happy, healthy lives and ALL have chances in life.
Here's an important difference from what other people have said: you have to act on how parents HAVE treated their kids, not how they might. Until Minority Report comes reality, we can't judge people in advance of what they might do to their kids. The state does have the right to remove kids from their parents, but its not just a simple choice like that: care homes are crap. Having known some people who have been in them, they are awful places to be, no matter how good and caring the staff might be (and they often are not that even). So, in many cases staying with parents who are being treated for some condition (usually depression) would be much better for the kids.
Quote from: Darth Mandarb on Tue 28/09/2004 12:34:51Quote from: shbazjinkens on Tue 28/09/2004 06:45:16I thought this was the land of oppurtunity?Land of opportunity is great and democracy is great, but I really think that what America (can't speak for the rest of the world) is experiencing now is the dark-side of democracy.Ã, People expect too much from their so-called 'freedom'.Ã, They're unwilling to sacrifice ANYthing for the greater good.Ã, People have become so spoiled by personal freedom that any sense of something bigger than their own well being is lost.Ã, To me this is very sad.
By continuing to use this site you agree to the use of cookies. Please visit this page to see exactly how we use these.
Page created in 0.422 seconds with 15 queries.