I agree with you Calin, but is it fair to rate a game by just one or two to reflect the mass? Clearly the response you get to this thread isn't in line with "a reasonable game, worth a try". And if you want to forge the download count to change the rating, you have to go through a lot of trouble. Besides, when you don't let that be the main factor (opinion of the player is much more important), you can't change too much.
I see it as with reviewers. With some, if they have a bad day or if they just don't like what they see, you get a negative review. So when reading reviews, I always read more to get a well weighed picture of the subject. In this case, there's only one panel that you have to trust upon. Granted that they are right most of the time, I think it's a disadvantage for the less known games..
Other than that, you can have only 5 'degrees'. From 1, not worth a try, to 5, excellent (but there are only 4..). Where do you switch from one category to another? When showing the rating based on story, graphics, sound etc, like is done with the user rating, you get a much fairer image of the game.
I'll leave this off-topic rant (actually not off topic for your game) on this thread. Just to finish my argument... your game got compared to Trilby.. One of those games got 5 cups... ? And why does the public rate you at 83% at the moment? I say: 2 cups is not fair! Besides that, I can't match the panel's comment with the rating.
I see it as with reviewers. With some, if they have a bad day or if they just don't like what they see, you get a negative review. So when reading reviews, I always read more to get a well weighed picture of the subject. In this case, there's only one panel that you have to trust upon. Granted that they are right most of the time, I think it's a disadvantage for the less known games..
Other than that, you can have only 5 'degrees'. From 1, not worth a try, to 5, excellent (but there are only 4..). Where do you switch from one category to another? When showing the rating based on story, graphics, sound etc, like is done with the user rating, you get a much fairer image of the game.
I'll leave this off-topic rant (actually not off topic for your game) on this thread. Just to finish my argument... your game got compared to Trilby.. One of those games got 5 cups... ? And why does the public rate you at 83% at the moment? I say: 2 cups is not fair! Besides that, I can't match the panel's comment with the rating.


) I couldn't solve it and internet wasn't around (the way it is today). So you just asked around and played together with friends to see what they could come up with. Or once in a while called into a BBS (Bulletin Board System for the youngsters ) to see if you could find answers there. That's easier nowadays.