Messages

Happy Birthday, Tabata! I hope you and all your gifs have an amazing day!

There are a lot of good pitches here. I was stuck between two, but in the end I voted for the one that I think I personally would most like to play. A lot of these would make really great games, though!

Yeah, I'll play again. Whenever is convenient for everyone else.

Happy Birthday, AGA! I hope you have a great day!

How about something very loosely based on Agatha Christie's "And then there where none"?

Oh, that could be interesting. More murder mystery than monster hunting. I like the sound of that!

I'd also be interested to hear who the Seer scanned both nights and whether they got in touch with them and what kind of discussion went on between them.

Yeah, as Sinitrena said, I scanned Stupot on night one and you on night two. Stu and I mostly just discussed whether you were actually suspicious or just trying to help everyone.

YES! I curse you, wolves, with my Seer powers! Let's see how you like that!

But really, I deserve to be eaten for buggering that game up so spectacularly. I thought that gaining an ally would be more beneficial than finding a wolf so soon in the game. I should have scanned Mandle the first night, but I was worried that he would be eaten and my scan would be wasted. So I went for someone less likely to be attacked. Then on the second day, I didn't really want to vote for Adeel, but I was still so unsure about Mandle and I thought that lynching a possible wolf is better than lynching nobody at all. I should have refused to vote, or voted for tzachs, who I suspected the most at that point, which would have caused a tie and therefore no lynching that day. So then when I finally did scan Mandle, he gave himself away anyway.

So, yeah, I failed massively that round. But I have learned from it, and that's what is most important.

All in all, I really enjoyed aministrating this round and would love to do it again (with a different setting - same roles, just named differently -, otherwise the story-telling gets a bit boring)

Yeah, that would be great! I'll play again, whatever the setting!

I had honestly been hoping someone would call me out on the "no reason" rule.

If I'd been around that day then I would have done. I actually thought it was weird thing to ask everyone to do when I read through the posts later, but it was the night phase by then so I couldn't say anything and I'd forgotten about it by the next day. It still didn't ring any alarm bells, though, so I probably would have bought whatever excuse you came up with, anyway!

I'll add more thoughts once the game is officially over.

[tzachs]

Well, that's that, then. Although one non-wolf might as well get a win out of this so I'll vote tzachs.

Firstly, sorry Adeel! I really do regret voting for you now. 

Secondly, poor Stupot, what a way to go.

OK, so what now? Given that he was one of the main candidates last time, he caused the lynching of an innocent villager  and that Stupot was eaten after voting for him, surely our main suspect is Mandle? Can anyone think of any reason not to vote for him?

[Adeel]

OK, I'm still not sure but I need to make a move one way or another. I feel like Adeel is slightly more suspicious than Mandle, even though that could be because he's a fool rather than a wolf. I don't feel like Mandle is deliberately trying to be deceiving, although I could be very wrong about that. So, with trepidation, I'm going for Adeel.

This is so confusing! I must admit, I was also thinking the same as tzachs about Adeel, that he may be the fool rather than a wolf. Although, I was also pretty convinced that VampireWombat was the fool, so my intuition is clearly not that great!

I'm not going to vote just yet, I'd like to see what Mandle has to say for himself before I decide.

Poor VampireWombat. We should have a toast of wolfsbane mojitos in his honour. Let's all raise a glass to VampireWombat!

Cassie makes a good point. Extra options are always a bonus.

Wow, Mandle, that's not unnerving at all...

Just so that everyone knows, I won't be around tomorrow. I must visit my sister in a nearby town, but I shall return with uncontaminated supplies! Even if everyone is too suspicious to eat them! I'll try and look in tomorrow evening, but it'll probably be the night phase by then. It doesn't look like we'll be lynching anyone, so hopefully I won't miss too much.

I'm leaning towards not lynching anyone, too. If we do lynch someone this phase, it'll most likely end up being the fool, which, while being a victory for him, brings the number of villagers down and ends up being a win for the wolves. So, yeah, giving the seer a bit of time to find something out seems like the best thing to do.

In fact, I'm not even going to trust any food that I haven't prepared myself...

So, are you volunteering to be the town cook, VampireWombat?

So, it begins again. It never ends well for the livestock, does it?

Definitely Cluedo! Monopoly, Trivial Pursuit and Scrabble would be good, too.

Good to hear that things are progressing well!

I'd also say B. It looks a lot neater.

I'll play again!

I forgot it in my earlier write-up: Thank you to my team. I think we worked great together, often without even discussing our strategies in too much details and I think we played off each other fairly well.

I forgot, too. Thanks to my wolf team for being so awesome! And thanks to Mandle for hosting, even if our boring tactics did send him to sleep.

Sorry that I suggested to use you as werewolf fodder and they listened.

Don't be sorry, it wasn't really because of that. We were trying to decide between eating someone who had been loud (you or dayowlron) or a quiet person (everyone else). We thought that eating a loud person would be safest, and we just happened to choose dayowlron. To be honest, we had so little to go on that first night that it could just have easily been you, and then the game would have been very different!