@Mandle:
@Baron:
Votes:
Spoiler
A couple interesting concepts here, maybe too many for such a short piece to give them all proper descriptions and weight. We have: the functionality of the spaceship; the lives or non-lives of the crew; the flight out of the universe; the memories of the main character. All these things, individually, could be very interesting, but they are a bit thrown together randomly and no part manages to really shine.
What isn't there is an actual connection to the topic (unless I missed something). Just calling a space ship "Devil" really doesn't make this a story about the devil (in whatever form), especially considering this note in the first post: "A story about a Tasmanian devil...? Eh, that's a bit of a stretch." This story was far more of a stretch.
Still, there's so much potentially fascinating stuff in here - You posted very early, I wish you had taken a bit more time to expand on several of the ideas present here.
What isn't there is an actual connection to the topic (unless I missed something). Just calling a space ship "Devil" really doesn't make this a story about the devil (in whatever form), especially considering this note in the first post: "A story about a Tasmanian devil...? Eh, that's a bit of a stretch." This story was far more of a stretch.
Still, there's so much potentially fascinating stuff in here - You posted very early, I wish you had taken a bit more time to expand on several of the ideas present here.
[close]
@Baron:
Spoiler
Brutal. But as it is so often with torture, the mental part might be stronger than the physical part.
It was fairly obvious where the story was going, considering it was made clear fairly early on that Orwell was a prisoner by showing the devil supervising him.
It's interesting that the physical torture Orwell is about to endure is almost a relief for him. And even more so the reason why he stops being a torturer himself: It clearly shows that he has something good in himself. What isn't clear is if the devil intents to destroy this good, if he just uses it to enhance the mental torture of Orwell or if we are even more in a purgatory setting, where showing some goodness leads to something better on the far horizon. - In short, there might be some philosophical concepts that could be explored here.
Also interesting is that ci´hild becomes the new torturer. Does that mean that Orwell was tortured before as well? And that the child will be tortured again as well as soon as he shows any scruple?
It was fairly obvious where the story was going, considering it was made clear fairly early on that Orwell was a prisoner by showing the devil supervising him.
It's interesting that the physical torture Orwell is about to endure is almost a relief for him. And even more so the reason why he stops being a torturer himself: It clearly shows that he has something good in himself. What isn't clear is if the devil intents to destroy this good, if he just uses it to enhance the mental torture of Orwell or if we are even more in a purgatory setting, where showing some goodness leads to something better on the far horizon. - In short, there might be some philosophical concepts that could be explored here.
Also interesting is that ci´hild becomes the new torturer. Does that mean that Orwell was tortured before as well? And that the child will be tortured again as well as soon as he shows any scruple?
[close]
Votes:
Spoiler
Baron - 2 points
Mandle - 1 point
Mandle - 1 point
[close]