Quote from: ddq on Mon 01/11/2010 14:09:38
Haven't thought about it too much, but 2 seems the most logical to me. If I borrow $5 from my friend to buy a sandwich, immediately pay him back, then discover there's a toe in my sandwich, I'd be the one who gets the refund. It be the same if, instead of my friend, it was my seeing eye monkey.
That's assuming credit has nothing to do with it. If Mr. B gets frequent flyer miles or something, he will have slightly profited from all situations.
Unless this is some sort of logic puzzle, 1 and 3 seem clearly unfair and 4 seems like the "simple" approach.
Just my two cents.
There was absolutely nothing wrong with the shoes, indeed Mr. A was thoroughly happy with his shoes.
Mr. B is not a frequent flier, and gets no other benefits from using his credit card.