Quote from: Andail on Thu 05/11/2009 17:24:06
Homeopathy is inherently unscientific, since the very theory behind it goes against both chemistry and common sense.
Yeah, I can accept that. This Water memory concept seems more like flipping tarot cards to me than fermenting antibiotics.
My line of thought still stands, however: If the placebo effect works (again, I've only quickly skimmed Wikipedia, which I assume is as reliable a source of reference as any) then can it be dismissed as a form of medicine? Seems unlikely to me.
It seems highly trivial to be suggesting that governments should spend their efforts deciding whether or not to make something that might be a form of medicine illegal, instead of focusing on the great many other areas which seem much higher priority in my mind.
Apologies to Snarky for derailing his thread. And of course, Tuomas, please do make sure you don't dig your nose with other people's snot on your fingers. That's just asking for trouble.
Nacho, just read your post, but are you certain? Wikipedia says these WHO chaps published a report (if this holds any consequence or not) stating it as 'effective treatment' (whatever this entails) for a whole bunch of nasty things.
I'll try to stop posting in here now (as I'm clearly asking more questions than I am answering), but am interested to read other people's thoughts
