NP: Anna Lee (5:51)... Let's take over this thread. I talked to our drummer and another friend of mine who's drummer, and they both say Portnoy doesn't play for the band but for himself. And to take this even further, in the last 3 albums, the worst songs have been composed by Portnoy... But I guess it's just what you look from a band. The best drummer is Neil Peart, absolutely, the Bill Bruford and then Phil Collins.
At least they've played Pull Me Under and that new U2 like song, I walk Beside You here... So, I reckon you all progmetal-heads there listen to Vanden Plas or something like that?
Oh, and I, being the happy owner of many records, still find it odd that, most people count King Crimson as a Prog metal band. Sure they have some heavy material on their new albums.
Quote from: dkh on Fri 24/02/2006 14:52:20
Here in Germany, nobody knows them except progressive metal fans like me.They are NEVER played on any kind of radio station and I bet that not even 1% of people here know their name.
At least they've played Pull Me Under and that new U2 like song, I walk Beside You here... So, I reckon you all progmetal-heads there listen to Vanden Plas or something like that?
Oh, and I, being the happy owner of many records, still find it odd that, most people count King Crimson as a Prog metal band. Sure they have some heavy material on their new albums.
Quote from: Helm on Fri 24/02/2006 15:10:23What I mean is, that Mike Portnoy makes it as Dream Theater as possible, granted that it's more like Chroma Key, but the drumming. I still say he doesn't play for the band. One of those who are great teachers and players, but could easily be replaced in a band. In a band that is not DT which is what Portnoy plays.
Tuomas, I see nothing 'random' in the way Portnoy plays, and his style can handle any tempo. I basically cannot follow your line of thinking at all since you even say OSI are like Theater.