I was going to join in on the first day, but didn't due to the expired certificate...
My first introduction to Dune was watching the Alan Smithee version of the movie on the Scifi Channel with my older brother. I've never actually seen the theatrical cut. I have read all of the original books and even the first 3 prequels and the one sequel meant to tie things up. I've also seen the miniseries several times. And I've played the game quite a few times.
I like a lot of the Lynch movie. Especially the costumes and actor choices for most characters. But Ian McNiece definitely was the better Baron. But yeah, Lynch definitely did some things to make it bad. Like the weirding modules, which were only okay because of how they worked in the game...
I'm still not sure about the guy chosen for Paul in the new movie. His voice is just wrong to me. Sounds more like a wimpy kid than someone who was raised by a Bene Gesserit.
But pretty much any other thoughts have been covered by others.
My first introduction to Dune was watching the Alan Smithee version of the movie on the Scifi Channel with my older brother. I've never actually seen the theatrical cut. I have read all of the original books and even the first 3 prequels and the one sequel meant to tie things up. I've also seen the miniseries several times. And I've played the game quite a few times.
I like a lot of the Lynch movie. Especially the costumes and actor choices for most characters. But Ian McNiece definitely was the better Baron. But yeah, Lynch definitely did some things to make it bad. Like the weirding modules, which were only okay because of how they worked in the game...
I'm still not sure about the guy chosen for Paul in the new movie. His voice is just wrong to me. Sounds more like a wimpy kid than someone who was raised by a Bene Gesserit.
But pretty much any other thoughts have been covered by others.