Farlander's response shows exactly how effective these messages are, to the point that we don't even see them as racist but as "fact," even though no legitimate historian or anthropologist would accept them as such.
For example, that all famine in Russia was caused by greed is of course in contrast to the view that all famine elsewhere in the world (such as the US during the same period) was caused by... nature? And the many times more deaths occuring in Capitalist or colonized countries (this is not rhetoric, but statistics) were natural. Also, "Soviets" has other issues in it besides just the anti-Soviet stuff.
It should also be noted that "paternalism" is one of the most effective hallmarks of racism--racism isn't just the "crazed hate" typified in hollywood movies, but a structural element allowing colonialism and neo-colonialism to continue. It isn't necessarily a personal failure as in "You're a racist--a total writeoff" -- but rather something we all face from time to time. I have studied racism for years, know both the idea that races are a myth and that saying so dilutes much of the very valuable activism, and still I have moments of my own zenophobia and racism. I just try not to get too defensive when someone points it out.
That said, I also love Tintin. A lot of people love Tintin, but that doesn't guarantee that you'll be able to create an effective team capable of creating the original spirit (edited not just for PC reasons, but to fit with Herge's more informed later vision).
Both of those said, I still encourage you to try, and at worse, fail. The world doesn't really NEED a lot more games, so even if you do fail, you should discover new skills you can apply to other things, even other games. I would certainly play a Tintin game and enjoy it, even if it wasn't "perfectly" rendered. You might have to a) construct a new story (or use his last story) or b) amalgamate elements from several to allow puzzles to exist that aren't already all spelled out in the more popular books.
So I wish you luck, but since I'm already not working on two other group projects (for now anyway), I can't commit to this one. It sounds fun, however.
For example, that all famine in Russia was caused by greed is of course in contrast to the view that all famine elsewhere in the world (such as the US during the same period) was caused by... nature? And the many times more deaths occuring in Capitalist or colonized countries (this is not rhetoric, but statistics) were natural. Also, "Soviets" has other issues in it besides just the anti-Soviet stuff.
It should also be noted that "paternalism" is one of the most effective hallmarks of racism--racism isn't just the "crazed hate" typified in hollywood movies, but a structural element allowing colonialism and neo-colonialism to continue. It isn't necessarily a personal failure as in "You're a racist--a total writeoff" -- but rather something we all face from time to time. I have studied racism for years, know both the idea that races are a myth and that saying so dilutes much of the very valuable activism, and still I have moments of my own zenophobia and racism. I just try not to get too defensive when someone points it out.
That said, I also love Tintin. A lot of people love Tintin, but that doesn't guarantee that you'll be able to create an effective team capable of creating the original spirit (edited not just for PC reasons, but to fit with Herge's more informed later vision).
Both of those said, I still encourage you to try, and at worse, fail. The world doesn't really NEED a lot more games, so even if you do fail, you should discover new skills you can apply to other things, even other games. I would certainly play a Tintin game and enjoy it, even if it wasn't "perfectly" rendered. You might have to a) construct a new story (or use his last story) or b) amalgamate elements from several to allow puzzles to exist that aren't already all spelled out in the more popular books.
So I wish you luck, but since I'm already not working on two other group projects (for now anyway), I can't commit to this one. It sounds fun, however.