Quote from: Nikolas on Fri 15/09/2006 11:03:54
The original question though was if you would feel betrayed of osme sort if an author made some games for free (or a series), thus luring you into a universe, or a game and then started asking games, as it would be the case of Aprentice III. Would that be a bad thing? Hercual Efforts making a new game and releaseing it commercially is perfectly fine, but the Apprentice 3? Just wondering really...
I think, personally, that the contribution of writing several games and giving them away free of charge is enough that charging for the next one to get some material reward for all that contribution is completely fine.
The fact that it's part of a series is not really a problem as although they carry over characters and an overall theme/plot line you get closure at the end of each story. However, I'd feel slightly differently if, as in our case, it was a game where the story was spread over the three games. Although there may be climaxes, cliffhangers, and closure to smaller sub-plots it is essentially three parts of the same game and and story. To release the first two for free, then out of the blue decide to charge for the third one would be a bit iffy in this case, unless of course this intention was stated before or when the first was released, as with Captain Brawe.
I would however, say that perhaps the biggest reasons to avoid charging for them is because it would pretty much guarantee that you would have a tiny percentage of people playing them compared to the previous games, and also that people will be much less forgiving of their shortcomings (and all games have those) -- these are the primary reasons we have no intention to charge for FE.
Also I doubt any 2D point-and-click would sell enough to compensate for these eventualities.