Quote from: Creamy on Sun 25/10/2020 18:49:50QuoteI Googled it, but I'm not sure this is the right answer. Is this the version you are telling?Spoiler
The seagull tastes nothing like a 'seagull' that this person ate before...right?[close]
Yes. The story's kinda gross.
It’s alright, but the problem with those riddles is that they can’t really be solved just based on the riddle. It requires A LOT of investigation through probing the riddler. I think a good riddle should stand up to those Agatha Christie rules (ie you can’t hide anything from the reader; they should be given enough to figure the mystery out, etc).
The seagull riddle reminds me of another one I heard in a similar vein (if anyone wants to try it):
A young girl opens a door in her house and this changes everything she knows forever. What was the door?
(People might have heard that one before. Otherwise, I don’t think it is possible to guess what the door is without lots of investigation.)