I think Other Worlds did have a low profile on these forums and hadn't been pimped here. Here's my suppositions as to why maybe it hadn't got a buzz about it:
1. It hadn't had a build up beforehand. Now, Cirque de Zale didn't either, it also "just appeared" on the forums but the difference was:
2. Other Worlds' screenshots don't sell the game. Now, this is no fault of alkis, but 90% of AGS games that have sprite-type characters over photographic backgrounds are crap. OW and EEF are the only really good examples I can think of. Cirque, on the other hand, looked just like a classic Lucas game, and that look is very popular around here.
3. More on the build-up: many games generate their best buzz not from their GiP thread, which can tend to be drowned out by dross, but rather by the Critics Lounge (2nd most popular board on AGS, remember) on background, animations, etc.
4. You released at the end of the year, while 7DAS, A2, CdZ were all earlier, so had time to build up a fan base. While year-end-releases benfit Oscar candidates, it does tend to hinder AGS games. Also, the game-of-the-month feature had ToaK and CdZ. And BJ3, A2, ToaK and 7DAS had "big name" AGSers behind them.
5. You had a good review on JA+ which some people will see as a big minus, 'cause they hate JA+
EDIT:
6. Kinoko is female which will automatic double all interest on the forums in anyone's game. See also Ola's PoE and Dart's involvement in ToaK. Or maybe its just that females are on avearge twice as good at making games?
EDIT 2: re-reading that edit makes it look really sexist, actually. I don't want to imply that CdZ only got interest becuase of the gender of the author. It's a really great game!
1. It hadn't had a build up beforehand. Now, Cirque de Zale didn't either, it also "just appeared" on the forums but the difference was:
2. Other Worlds' screenshots don't sell the game. Now, this is no fault of alkis, but 90% of AGS games that have sprite-type characters over photographic backgrounds are crap. OW and EEF are the only really good examples I can think of. Cirque, on the other hand, looked just like a classic Lucas game, and that look is very popular around here.
3. More on the build-up: many games generate their best buzz not from their GiP thread, which can tend to be drowned out by dross, but rather by the Critics Lounge (2nd most popular board on AGS, remember) on background, animations, etc.
4. You released at the end of the year, while 7DAS, A2, CdZ were all earlier, so had time to build up a fan base. While year-end-releases benfit Oscar candidates, it does tend to hinder AGS games. Also, the game-of-the-month feature had ToaK and CdZ. And BJ3, A2, ToaK and 7DAS had "big name" AGSers behind them.
5. You had a good review on JA+ which some people will see as a big minus, 'cause they hate JA+
EDIT:
6. Kinoko is female which will automatic double all interest on the forums in anyone's game. See also Ola's PoE and Dart's involvement in ToaK. Or maybe its just that females are on avearge twice as good at making games?

EDIT 2: re-reading that edit makes it look really sexist, actually. I don't want to imply that CdZ only got interest becuase of the gender of the author. It's a really great game!