Quote from: DGMacphee on Thu 23/10/2003 18:35:55Quote from: SSH on Thu 23/10/2003 17:14:56
Ummmm.... being prolific isn't necessarily a good thing: it just means yo umade a lot. Now, Speilberg is a great director, but that aint what you said.
But you've essentially proven my point anyway, so why be critical and mince with my words?
It's pretty pedantic if you ask me.
Granted!
Quote
But it's also hypocritical, if you'll read my next response.QuoteLucas a great writer? His dialogue is infamous.
Then you obviously have never seen THX-1138 or American Graffiti.
Also, writing a screenplay isn't just dialogue -- There's character, story, action, movement and subtext, which are facets where Lucas excells.
Also, keep in mind I said "conceived" by three of the most talenter writers -- Lucas didn't actually write it but came up with the story (One of Lucas' stronger points) with Phil Kauffman.
Lucas is a great ideas man, that I can agree with. That he is a great writer, I find more difficult to accept.
Quote
I find it hypocritical that first off you you criticise me for using the wrong word, then in the next breath you don't properly read my actual words in your next response.
Well, I was trying to check whether you did mean "prolific" as a reason fo rthe movie being great. And what I disagreed with about Lucas was whether he was a great writer which IS what you wrote.
QuoteQuoteIs Titanic a great movie?
What's you're point here?
Oscars do not a great movie make. However, I do think that Titanic is great. I could quote awards, box-office, etc. but the reason it is great is this: a huge number of people who saw Titanic went back to see it again and again, not just on DVD or Video but in the cinema. The reason they did this is becuase Cameron crafted a movie that could have ended oh so differently if the just got to Leo a bit sooner and the audience wanted to believe that next time they saw the movie, it would. It was also a tragedy and all the best stories are tragedies. Most people who don't like Titanic do so out of Leo-envy.
QuoteOf these, only LA Confidential has any greatness. The others are Sentimental, Depressing and Stereotypical and Sentimental respectively. Are you trying to say that Good Will Hunting wasn't as sentimental as Titanic? It had Robin Williams in it!
In fact, in the same year as Titanic, you had four great films: LA Confidential, Good Will Hunting, The Full Monty, and As Good As It Gets.
Quote
So your whole Titanic theory totally sucks, SSH, because for every Titanic there's about 10 or 20 other worthy films in the Oscar race (Raiders included) that get ignored by people like you.
I think Raiders is a great movie. I never said it wasn't.
QuoteI count tributes as a total ripoff
This was ironic, trying to mock your assertion that all parodies are rip-offs. Sorry that you took it seriously.
Quote
But let me tell you something: tributes (and any kind of total rip-offs) aren't a bad thing.
Hmmm, backtracking by trying to redefine a derogatory term you used first yourself, eh?