What' s the problem with Helm?
Has Helm told something like "You are bad" or "Every band trying to be original succeds, but you failed miserabilly..."? No. He said they are good. He said that almost no one, nowadays, can archieve originallity.
Is that so serious? I think it' s a critic... a good one, contructive and real, IMO. 0% of harshness, and some degree of gentle obliging intentions.
I didn' t like the tunes, either (Thanks Ghormak for opening the path). It' s not bad, but it doesn' t really turn me mad of emotion. I am not saying that the music is bad, or that it won' t appeal anybody. Cameron shouldn' t feel attacked if someone says something bad about the melodies. I didn' t like strawberries either and people seems to love them.
Huw, I don' t know if you hae a personal matter with Helm... He has a particular way of posting, I admitt it...
I must sometimes remember who he is in person, and how would "sound" that sentence he has written, if told by him, "live", to understand the criticism and see how lack of wickedness the sentence really is.
I am really open to discuss about if he, DGMacPhee, or myself included, should relax a bit when posting. I do. I don' t really care about "hard posting", because after some bad experiences, I learned to realise that people is not so harsh as sounds when posing, and 99% of the times bitter arguings are just missunderstandings.
But if some "soft" members like you want me to post in a more moderate way, I am open to discuss about it.
But not because of this stupidity. If I am in a jury, and I know I am judging a criminal who has avoided jail before because he had good lawyers, I am not going to imprison him now if, for once, he is innocent. Dud round, my friend.
QuoteYou are good, but not too original. Being original in the world of music is almost impossible. You should move to label youselves as good, better than "original"
Has Helm told something like "You are bad" or "Every band trying to be original succeds, but you failed miserabilly..."? No. He said they are good. He said that almost no one, nowadays, can archieve originallity.
Is that so serious? I think it' s a critic... a good one, contructive and real, IMO. 0% of harshness, and some degree of gentle obliging intentions.
I didn' t like the tunes, either (Thanks Ghormak for opening the path). It' s not bad, but it doesn' t really turn me mad of emotion. I am not saying that the music is bad, or that it won' t appeal anybody. Cameron shouldn' t feel attacked if someone says something bad about the melodies. I didn' t like strawberries either and people seems to love them.
Huw, I don' t know if you hae a personal matter with Helm... He has a particular way of posting, I admitt it...
I must sometimes remember who he is in person, and how would "sound" that sentence he has written, if told by him, "live", to understand the criticism and see how lack of wickedness the sentence really is.
I am really open to discuss about if he, DGMacPhee, or myself included, should relax a bit when posting. I do. I don' t really care about "hard posting", because after some bad experiences, I learned to realise that people is not so harsh as sounds when posing, and 99% of the times bitter arguings are just missunderstandings.
But if some "soft" members like you want me to post in a more moderate way, I am open to discuss about it.
But not because of this stupidity. If I am in a jury, and I know I am judging a criminal who has avoided jail before because he had good lawyers, I am not going to imprison him now if, for once, he is innocent. Dud round, my friend.